Wednesday, April 30, 2025
25.9 C
Singapore
Home Blog Page 416

Money matters made fun for kids aged 7 to 15: How one game-changing financial app is teaching SG parents to empower their kids

SINGAPORE: In an era of increasingly prevalent digital transactions, cashless payments are now the norm for everyday activities such as dining and transportation.

A recent study by Yahoo Singapore and Milieu Insight, reported by The Straits Times, highlights this trend, revealing that 38% of Gen Z Singaporeans prefer mobile e-wallets and digital payment services.

In comparison, 41% of millennials favour contactless credit or debit cards.

With the minimum age to open a bank account in Singapore typically set at 16, younger generations—especially Gen Alpha, those born after 2009—are growing up in a world where digital technology is woven into the fabric of daily life.

For these children, mastering cashless systems and managing finances digitally is becoming a vital skill.

OCBC has launched the MyOwn Account to support this financial literacy journey, specifically designed for children aged 7 to 15.

This innovative account allows kids to manage their own bank accounts through an app, all under parental supervision.

With features that include digital payments, QR code scanning at merchants, and access to PayNow, young users can navigate the world of finance while learning responsible money management.

Real experiences

To better understand the impact of this initiative, The Straits Times spoke with parents who have trialled the app with their children.

Review #1: Fostering financial independence

Jassmin Peter-Berntzen, a mother of 10-year-old Andreas, shares her insights on using the MyOwn Account.

“Until now, my son’s experience with money was limited to cash I handed him for snacks and lunches.

With OCBC’s MyOwn Account, I saw an opportunity to help him learn to manage his own money while I maintained oversight.”

Jassmin found the account setup process straightforward, using her existing OCBC app to get started. Andreas created his login and learned about password security, which made him feel mature and responsible.

The app’s intuitive design made it easy for him to navigate.

A standout feature for Jassmin was the automatic weekly spending cap, allowing her to set a recurring pocket money transfer.

This gives Andreas the freedom to manage his spending and simplifies Jassmin’s role in providing his allowance.

“Real-time push notifications keep me updated on his transactions, and I can monitor his spending through a mirrored dashboard on my app,” Jassmin explains.

This oversight has sparked valuable discussions about prioritizing needs over wants, empowering Andreas to think critically about his spending decisions.

The account also includes engaging educational comic strips about budgeting and digital banking, which Jassmin appreciates as tools for deeper conversations about money with her son.

“One suggestion is to add a pie chart feature to visually categorize spending, which could help Andreas understand where his money goes,” she said.

Review #2: Teaching teens to budget wisely

Terence Lim, the father of 14-year-old Ryan, expresses a different perspective.

“Initially, I preferred my son to use cash until he was ready for his own debit card.

But with the evolving landscape of banking, the OCBC MyOwn Account provides a practical introduction to managing real money.”

Terence finds the app user-friendly for transferring pocket money. Currently, Ryan receives $150 monthly for lunches and transportation, with flexibility to adjust as needed for school-related expenses.

As Ryan matures, Terence plans to increase his allowance and encourage more financial independence.

“The dashboard allows Ryan to track his spending, teaching him valuable budgeting skills that will be essential as he plans for larger expenses in the future,” Terence notes.

“I want him to be financially savvy, whether it’s saving for a graduation trip or a future car,” he added.

Like Jassmin, Terence appreciates the mirrored dashboard feature, which allows him to monitor Ryan’s financial activities.

The app’s security features, such as a Money Lock and a ‘kill switch’ for emergencies, provide additional peace of mind.

“I’d love to see a ‘virtual piggy bank’ feature where kids can set savings goals, fostering a culture of regular saving and financial discipline.”

Teaching about financial responsibility

As cashless payments become integral to daily life, initiatives like OCBC’s MyOwn Account are crucial for teaching young generations about financial responsibility.

By empowering children with the tools to navigate digital banking, parents can help shape financially savvy adults who are well-equipped to thrive in a cashless society.

Rentvesting trend in Singapore: Renters are now investing in homes they’ll never call home

0

SINGAPORE: In today’s challenging housing market, many renters are finding a clever workaround — investing in properties outside their expensive cities while continuing to live in their rental apartments.

This strategy, known as “rentvesting” allows individuals to build equity without sacrificing their current lifestyle.

The appeal of ‘rentvesting’

A South China Morning Post (SCMP) report states that as home prices soar—up over 51% since pre-pandemic levels, with median starter home prices reaching $250,000—many prospective buyers are left feeling priced out.

According to Danielle Hale, chief economist at Realtor.com, this trend makes sense for renters who have extra cash but wish to remain in high-cost areas.

Instead of buying a home in an unaffordable market, they are looking to more budget-friendly regions where their savings can go further, allowing for a substantial down payment.

New wave of homeownership

Take Cole Flynn, for example. A Long Island renter in his early 20s, Flynn co-owns a townhouse in Tampa, Florida, with two friends.

They leveraged their bonuses and partnered with Nestment, a company that helps first-time buyers navigate the market, to purchase the property for $357,000 last year.

Flynn shares, “We’re building equity in a home right now before we turn 25,” something he thought was impossible given New York’s sky-high prices.

With an expected 16% annual return on their investment—factoring in rental income and property appreciation—Flynn and his friends are reaping the benefits of this innovative approach to homeownership.

Rising trends among small investors

The trend is gaining momentum nationwide. Small investors—those owning up to 10 properties—accounted for nearly 63% of investor purchases earlier this year, according to Realtor.com.

This marks a significant shift, with more individuals seeking creative ways to enter the real estate market.

Challenges of remote property management

However, rentvesting isn’t without its challenges. Managing a rental property can be demanding, especially from afar.

As rent prices stabilize in some areas and operational costs rise—like homeowners’ insurance—landlords must be prepared for the realities of property management.

Flynn and his friends handle maintenance through Taskrabbit, ensuring that their first tenants, who signed a one-year lease, have a smooth experience.

Renting in Singapore

A Reddit user said that young Singaporeans do this to “Live with parents in their landed property to benefit from the spacious environment and save on the expenses of hiring a helper while renting out their BTO for extra income.”

Likewise, Today Online recently highlighted an ERA Realty White Paper highlighting a significant trend — the increasing number of young Singaporeans, particularly those aged 26 to 35, investing in new private properties.

This shift is primarily attributed to rising incomes and the desire of these young buyers to circumvent the age and income restrictions associated with acquiring new public flats.

Many young Singaporeans believe that purchasing private property is a valuable investment.

A real estate expert pointed out that while property prices have risen in line with income growth, additional factors influence this trend.

Notably, compared to public flats, the greater availability of condominiums launched in recent years may also be crucial in driving this shift toward private property ownership.

As the housing landscape evolves, aspiring homeowners must embrace innovative strategies like rentvesting to achieve their dreams.

This approach allows them to build equity and helps them stay connected to the vibrant urban lifestyles they love.

As it is, creativity is key in a market where traditional pathways to homeownership have increasingly become difficult.

Read also: Singaporean says, ‘After I pay for the house for 30 years, it’s still not mine because when 99 years are up, I have to return it. Then why even buy it?’

HDB flat owner triumphs in High Court over renovation dispute against contractor

0

SINGAPORE: In a landmark ruling on October 23, the High Court reversed the 2023 deregistration of renovation contractor Concept Werk, allowing homeowner Lye Yew Cheong to pursue his claims in court over a protracted renovation dispute.

This decision marks a significant victory for consumers in a sector often beset by complaints.

The renovation

According to The Straits Times, the saga began in July 2021 when Mr Lye hired Concept Werk, directed by Keith Xie and Sonia Tay, to renovate his HDB flat.

The initial renovation estimate was $123,000, with Mr Lye providing a 20% deposit.

However, costs escalated to $144,656, and the couple, having vacated their home for the project, faced numerous delays and defects that kept them out of their flat until June 2022—more than six months later than promised.

Despite assurances from Ms Tay in early 2022 regarding the rectification of defects at no additional charge, communication soured by March 2023.

Compounding the issue, Ms Tay resigned as a director in October 2021, and Mr Xie closed the company’s accounts and deregistered Concept Werk in May 2023, all while the dispute with Mr Lye lingered.

The disappearing

In October 2023, Mr Lye sought justice through the Small Claims Tribunal but withdrew his case when he learned Concept Werk had ceased to exist.

Undeterred, he applied to the High Court to reverse the deregistration. While the Accounting and Corporate Regulatory Authority (Acra) did not oppose this move, Mr. Xie contested it.

On Sept 16, High Court Judge Goh Yihan heard the case. On Oct 23, he ordered Acra to restore Concept Werk’s registration, effectively allowing the company to exist as if it had never been deregistered.

Justice Goh emphasized that Mr Lye had legitimate grounds for his grievances, and his legal claims were neither hopeless nor devoid of merit.

This ruling also sheds light on the renovation sector, which has been a focal point of consumer complaints.

The Consumers Association of Singapore reported 1,168 complaints against renovation contractors in 2023 alone, a slight decline from previous years but still ranking as one of the highest categories of grievances.

Mr Lye’s victory paves the way for him to seek damages while sending a strong message about consumer rights in the renovation industry.

Represented by Mohamed Nawaz Kamil from August Law Corporation, Mr Lye’s case illustrates the challenges homeowners face when contractors fail to fulfil their obligations.

As the situation develops, Mr. Lye is now poised to pursue his claims against Concept Werk, seeking accountability for the alleged mishandling of his home renovation project.

Singapore consumers’ confidence in AI drops 11% over the past 12 months due to poor experiences

0

SINGAPORE: Singapore consumers’ confidence in AI use by institutions is on a decline.

A recent Qualtrics report showed an 11% drop in comfort levels with AI over the past year, whether they’re used to place orders or provide medical advice.

The report surveyed consumers’ trust in AI across various sectors and revealed that six in 10 Singaporeans now have low confidence in organisations to use AI responsibly.

According to the Singapore Business Review, the report also revealed growing concerns among consumers about AI use in customer service, with half preferring to connect with human agents, four in 10 worried about data misuse, and a similar number dissatisfied with the quality of interactions.

Isabelle Zdatny, a Customer Loyalty Specialist at Qualtrics, observed that companies are more excited about using AI than consumers and noted that there’s still much work needed to persuade everyone of its benefits.

She explained that AI works best in customer service when it focuses on solving specific issues that matter to people.

Although reports of poor customer experiences in Singapore have decreased over the past year, consumer trust has dropped by 4%, likelihood to recommend by 5%, and satisfaction with brands by 4%.

According to Qualtrics, the leading causes of poor experiences in Singapore include communication issues (43%), service delivery failures (42%), pricing concerns (39%), and unsatisfactory employee interactions (37%).

Mobile providers, hospitals, automotive companies, and parcel delivery services received the most complaints from consumers about poor experiences, while airlines, streaming services, and department stores saw fewer complaints.

While some consumers choose to report negative experiences, others prefer to remain silent.

Qualtrics found that Singaporean consumers are seven percentage points less likely to give feedback on poor experiences, with most opting to share these issues only with family or friends.

Ms Zdatny noted that customers expect better experiences but are often unwilling to share the feedback brands need to make changes.

She suggested that brands rethink their engagement strategies and move beyond traditional surveys. /TISG

Read also: Singapore firms prefer using RAG and SLMs over chatbots, LLMs, and digital assistants compared to global peers

Featured image by Depositphotos (for illustration purposes only)

Apple’s iPhone exports from India surge to nearly US$6B amid manufacturing shift away from China

0

ASIA: Apple’s iPhone exports from India significantly increased by one-third in the six months leading up to September.

The US firm exported nearly US$6 billion (S$7.95 billion) worth of iPhones made in India, marking a one-third increase in value compared to the previous year, according to sources who wished to remain anonymous.

If this trend continues, annual exports could surpass roughly US$10 billion (S$13.24 billion) for the fiscal year 2024, The Business Times reports.

The company is rapidly expanding its manufacturing capabilities in India, taking advantage of local subsidies, a skilled workforce, and improving technological resources.

India plays a crucial role in Apple’s strategy to reduce dependence on China, where operational risks have grown due to increasing tensions between the US and China.

Three of Apple’s main suppliers, Taiwan’s Foxconn Technology Group, Pegatron, and India’s Tata Electronics, assemble iPhones in southern India.

Foxconn, located just outside Chennai, is the leading supplier in the country, accounting for half of India’s iPhone exports.

Tata Group’s electronics division exported around US$1.7 billion (S$2.25 billion) in iPhones from its factory in Karnataka from April to September.

This marked a significant milestone as Tata became the first Indian assembler of Apple’s popular product after acquiring its unit from Wistron last year.

The reported dollar figures reflect the estimated factory gate value of the devices, not the retail prices.

According to federal trade ministry data, iPhones have become vital to India’s smartphone exports, helping the category emerge as the top export to the US, valued at US$2.9 billion (S$3.84 billion) in the first five months of the current fiscal year.

This is an increase from just US$5.2 million (S$6.89 billion) in annual smartphone exports to the US five years ago before Apple ramped up its manufacturing efforts in the country.

Despite this growth, Apple holds just under 7 per cent of India’s smartphone market, largely dominated by Chinese brands like Xiaomi, Oppo, and Vivo.

While the Indian market is still relatively small for iPhones on a global scale, Apple continues to make big bets.

Support from the Indian government, especially under Prime Minister Narendra Modi, has been crucial in helping Apple produce its high-end iPhone 16 Pro and Pro Max models in India this year.

These models feature enhanced cameras and premium titanium bodies. Apple is also looking to expand its retail presence, with plans for new stores in tech hubs like Bangalore and Pune.

In 2023, Apple CEO Tim Cook launched the company’s first retail locations in Mumbai and New Delhi, marking a significant step for the brand in India.

The recent store openings, combined with an aggressive online sales strategy and a growing middle class eager to own Apple products, helped boost the company’s annual revenue in India to a record US$8 billion (S$10.6 billion) for the year ending March.

This increase in Apple’s success in India contrasts with the challenges it faces in China, where economic growth has slowed following strict COVID-19 lockdowns and ongoing property market issues.

While Apple continues to rely heavily on China for a significant portion of its manufacturing and sales, it is clear that India is becoming an increasingly important part of its global strategy.

In the fiscal year ending March 2024, Apple assembled around US$14 billion (S$18.54 billion)  worth of iPhones in India, doubling its production and accelerating efforts to diversify its manufacturing base beyond China.

Approximately US$10 billion (S$13.24 billion) of this total was exported. /TISG

Read also: Nvidia briefly surpasses Apple as most valuable company before market close, hitting US$3.53T

Featured image by Depositphotos

Singapore stocks opened nearly unchanged on Tuesday’s open—STI slightly rose by 0.02%

0

SINGAPORE: Singapore stocks opened nearly unchanged on Tuesday, Oct 29, following positive movements in US and European markets the previous day.

The Straits Times Index (STI) slightly rose by 0.02% or 0.71 points, to 3,584.79 at 9:01 am, as reported by The Business Times.

There were more gainers than losers in the broader market, with 60 stocks up against 56 down. About 26.8 million shares, worth S$43.3 million, were traded.

SinoCloud Group led the trading volume. The IT services provider’s shares increased by 5.9%, adding S$0.001 to reach S$0.018 after 2.8 million shares were exchanged.

Other actively traded stocks included agri-food company Japfa, which climbed 13.9%, or S$0.05, to close at S$0.41, and Nanofilm, a nanotechnology company, whose shares rose by 4.9%, or S$0.04, bringing its price to S$0.865.

The banking sector also performed well at the open. DBS rose by 0.2%, or S$0.07, to S$39.15. OCBC Bank edged up by 0.1%, or S$0.01, to S$15.28. United Overseas Bank (UOB) saw a gain of 0.2%, or S$0.05, bringing its price to S$32.46.

In the US, Wall Street stocks rose on Monday as a busy week of earnings reports and economic data began, with markets also keeping an eye on the final stages of the US presidential campaign.

As markets focused on this week’s earnings reports from major tech companies like Apple, Amazon, and Meta, the Dow Jones Industrial Average climbed 0.7% to 42,387.57.

The S&P 500 increased by 0.3% to 5,823.52, while the tech-heavy Nasdaq Composite Index rose by 0.3%, reaching 18,567.19.

In Europe, the main stock index rose on Monday, as gains in most sectors offset the decline in energy stocks due to falling oil prices.

Investors are also anticipating important economic data and major US tech earnings to be released later this week.

The pan-European Stoxx 600 rose 0.4% to 520.95. /TISG

Read also: Singapore shares opened on a positive note on Monday—STI rose by 0.1%

Featured image by Depositphotos

Singaporeans are getting 50-80% price discounts to enjoy delicious unsold food through new surplus food app

0

SINGAPORE: If you’re someone who hates waste, loves to eat, and wants to do your bit to save the planet, then the Yindii app is just for you.

The surplus food app, made available to Singaporeans just a few months ago, allows diners to “rescue” yummy but yet-unsold food from food and beverage establishments for half the price or even at an 80 per cent discount.

It truly feels like an all-win proposition. Not only does using Yindii help businesses, but it also helps the environment and your wallet and satisfies your tummy.

Yindii, also available in Hong Kong and Thailand, says, “Save the planet by doing what you love the most… EATING.”

Fb screengrab/ Yindii Singapore

The company’s mission is to raise awareness concerning the alarming amount of food waste generated— perhaps as much as one-third each day — and empower everyone to contend for a greener planet “one meal at a time.”

A world “where no food produced gets wasted,” as Yindii’s vision statement says.

The company is endeavouring to make this happen through its merchant partners. Together with them, Yindii offers surprise bags at least half their original price.

“You won’t know exactly what’s inside, but you’ll be making a big impact by reducing waste and promoting sustainability!” Yindii says.

A number of high-profile F & B establishments have already partnered with Yindii, including Paul’s Boulangerie, Park Backerei, Delifrance, So France, The Providore, Baker & Cook, Supergreen, Avorush, Heybo, Crust & Crumbs, Pita Bakery, Duke Bakery, Saladstop, Pita House, Celine Gelato, Windowsill Pies, Edith Patisserie, Chicken Pie Kitchen, and Sarah’s Loft.

To join the band of Yindii-loving earth savers is as easy as 1-2-3.

One, download the Yindii app here.

Two, choose your favourite F & B place among the company’s partner merchants and place your order.

Three, pay for your order and pick it up at their store at the end of the day.

Each kilo of food bought through the Yindii app, instead of being thrown away, is equal to 2.5 kilos of carbon dioxide emissions offset.

@flatburgersflatbuns

(one of) MY FAV BAKERIES IN SG 🥯🥖🥐🍞 watch till the end to find out how to get MORE THAN 50% OFF THEIR BREADS 🤫🤐 #bread #breadsg #dukebakery #sgfood #sgfoodie #sgfoodporn #sgfoodtrend #bakerysg #yindii #yindiiapp #sgtiktok #sgfoodiesfyp #sgfoodies #fyp #fypシ゚ #fyppppppppppppppppppppppp

♬ APT. – ROSÉ & Bruno Mars

Some Instagram users share how Yindii has worked for them, like the woman below who got 55 per cent off on four pies from Chicken Pie Kitchen.

The photos in the featured image above are from @flatburgersflatbuns on TikTok. /TISG

Read related: S’pore households can reduce their S$342m worth of food waste every year

“So unprofessional!” — S’poreans call out wedding photographers who ruined a couple’s proposal moment by shouting instructions at them

SINGAPORE: Getting engaged is one of the most memorable occasions in a couple’s life; a moment, quite understandably, they want to remember with joy.

This is probably why many Singaporeans sympathized with a couple when their photographer, who was paid S$4000, spoke so loudly during the proposal that it ruined the couple’s moment.

Twitch livestreamer @julynnlao posted videos of this particular ruined moment over Instagram and TikTok recently, getting hundreds of thousands of views, plus a whole lot of comments and reactions from netizens.

@julynnlau

😮‍💨😮‍💨

♬ original sound – Julynn Lau – Julynn Lau

“POV: Your photographer thinks she’s the main character of the proposal and missed the most important part of the engagement,” Ms Lao wrote.

Indeed, in a loud and rather strident voice, the photographer can be heard in the background directing what should have been an intimate and spontaneous moment.

The scene had certainly been set beautifully. The young couple is on the beach at night in front of a lit sign that reads, “Marry me.”

While it can be argued that Ms Lau knew what was coming and the whole shebang was no longer a surprise to her, she nevertheless deserved her precious moment with her boyfriend.

As her boyfriend addressed Ms Lau tenderly, the photographer can be heard calling out, “You can just kneel down already, kneel down.”

Being interrupted, her boyfriend asks the photographer, “Now?” to which the photographer answers him with, “Ya ya, just do it ya.”

As he proposes to her while telling her she’ll no longer be his girlfriend but his fiancée and asking her to marry him, the photographer can still be heard talking to other people, and her voice is louder than the couple’s.

“Wide shot, wide shot, wide shot,” a man’s voice, presumably part of the photography team, can be heard.

Ms Lao added they had to do the voiceover for the entire proposal again afterwards because the photography team had been so loud.

“If this happened to your proposal, what would you do?” she asked.

Perhaps one of the most exasperating parts of the video is when the boyfriend puts an engagement ring on Ms Lau’s finger, and the photographer can be heard calling out for Ms Lau to move her hair away from her face for a better shot.

Ms Lau’s expression, which had been tender and joyous, suddenly stiffened. However, this seems to be only one part of what happened, and Ms Lau asked if she should post a “Part 2.”

Commenters on her video expressed how sorry they were that this had happened to the couple and called the photographers for their insensitive service and poor behaviour.

“The couple needs an official apology statement and full refund!!!” wrote one, while another said it was very “unprofessional on the photographer’s part.”

One photographer in the comments section had this take: “As a photographer … this makes me cry 😢 this might be our portfolio, but it’s a milestone memory of their lifetime.” /TISG

Read also: Celebrity photographer Walter Tan thanks Mediacorp artist Desmond Tan for his big break

Singapore’s job hiring activities fall 5% YoY amid stagnation in shipping, consumer goods, engineering, real estate, and oil & gas sectors 

SINGAPORE: The overall job hiring activities in Singapore fell by 5% compared to the same time last year amid stagnation in sectors such as shipping, consumer goods, engineering, real estate, and oil & gas, the Singapore Business Review reports.

However, September hiring activity rose by 7%, according to foundit.

In terms of the month-on-month (MoM) increase, the education sector led hiring as it rose 4% MoM, driven by more investments from the government and private companies.

The retail, trade and logistics, import, export, sectors also saw a 3% MoM increase in hiring.

In contrast, the Banking, Financial Services, and Insurance (BFSI) and the media and entertainment industries declined. The BFSI sector saw a 2% MoM drop, while media and entertainment fell by 1% MoM.

Looking at specific job roles, marketing and communications professionals saw the highest demand, with a 44% year-on-year (YoY) increase and a 30% MoM rise.

Purchase, logistics, and supply chain roles also had a 29% increase, while finance and accounts roles grew by 11%, and legal positions increased by 9%.

However, demand for sales and business development roles fell by 13% MoM. Meanwhile, roles in software, hardware, telecom, and healthcare were among the least in demand. /TISG

Featured image by Depositphotos (for illustration purposes only)

30yo man earning S$90-100K/year in MNC says he’d rather switch careers to work in Govt agency because it “feels more meaningful”

SINGAPORE: A 30-year-old man earning S$90 to 100K annually working in a fast-paced job at an MNC took to an online forum on Sunday (Oct 27) to openly weigh his thoughts on possibly switching careers.

According to the man, though his current job pays him well, “There are always new challenges that come along, and higher management has high expectations.”

“It’s becoming more stressful over the years as I gain seniority. I am not keen to outperform as my peers are very competitive. You will need to do much, much more to stand out,” he explained.

He added that the new job at a government agency “feels more meaningful.”

Searching for meaning

“The compensation is lower but still not too far off from my current (job), so I’m grateful for that.” He also added that it’s shift work and comes with a better sense of job security.

However, he added that the stress level of the job was unknown.

“As my career progresses, I think I will need to do ‘CCAs,’ which I probably will not fancy,” he said. “Otherwise, the main job scope should be quite repetitive.”

While many may think landing a corporate job is the end game, it didn’t appear to be so for this man after experiencing life at an MNC. He then wrote: “I kind of already decided to switch but am curious to hear what the rest think.”

Singaporeans took to the post’s comments section to share their two cents on the matter.

“I’m in this exact position now,” one shared, adding, “It’s super tough to keep up, and I’m struggling also. I’m thinking of working in a Community Center or something.”

Career switch at 30

According to an article by Forbes, many people change careers throughout their working lives.

People in their 30s, in particular, have unique advantages as they are more likely to have experience, a good set of skills, and a business network. Furthermore, they also tend to be more financially stable.

Some tips to keep in mind are to do a lot of self-reflection, weigh out their skills (especially transferable ones), and make use of their professional network.

Read also: Public sector worker says he’s “waiting eagerly for more layoffs” in Singapore if S’poreans don’t “let go of their ego, chasing private sector jobs”