Home News SG Politics Town councils’ lift performance: Ownself check (score) ownself?

Town councils’ lift performance: Ownself check (score) ownself?




- Advertisement -

By: Leong Sze Hian

After writing “Minister: 4 lift breakdowns per lift per year (score 2 out of 5) OK?” (Apr 10), I had a lingering naggy feeling that something wasn’t right.

All town councils’ lift performance “green”? 

You see – the latest Town Council Management Report (TCMR) FY2015 had all the town councils scoring “green” for “lift performance”.

- Advertisement -

So many breakdowns, increase lifts’ S & CC?

How can this be – when there have been so many reports of frequent lift breakdowns, people getting injured or killed, resulting in the imposition of an additional 14 per cent of the Service and Conservancy Charges (S & CC) to the sinking fund (increase in S & CC)?

Are the rest as bad as Bishan-Toa Payoh?

How can all the town councils have scored “green”, despite the above and the revelation now of the poor lift statistics for Bishan-Toa Payoh?

Something very wrong with the Town Council Management Report?

Do all these mean that there may be something very wrong with the TMCR and its scoring methodology?

Lift performance scoring methodology?

Well, let’s examine the lift performance scoring methodology.

Out of the total of 10 points – 4 is for the frequency of lift breakdowns, 5 for Average Lift ARD failure rate per month, and 1 point for the Percentage of lifts that break down frequently (equal to or more than 3 times a month).

The chances of equal to or more than 0.1% of the total number of lifts breaking down equal to or more than 3 times a month may be quite small, such that the 1 point allocated may be quite easy to attain.

As to the “Average Lift ARD failure rate per month” – I googled and found the following:

“the largest lift company in the market is satisfied with the failure rate during the blackout.

“The reliability of this device is very high and chances of failure are very small,” said Phuah Cheng Kok, Executive Vice-President, Fujitec.

“Because it is an electro-mechanical device that’s dependent on a battery, there is still a small chance that this device can fail because of age or equipment failure.”

He added: “So looking at the number of calls that were received during the blackout, out of the whole of Singapore, there were only 20 cases, which makes it one in every 1,000 chance of failure. So it’s a very good statistic”.

Easy to score points?

So, does it mean that the chances of scoring high for this sub-category may be arguably, quite easy?

Why so many points to the “easy scores” sub-categories?

If this is the case, why allocate so many points (5) to this “easy scoring” category, but only 4 points to lift breakdowns which arguably may be more important and significant but harder to score well?

Ownself Check (score) Ownself?

It does seem looking at the above – that the lift performance scoring methodology may arguably be – by design – intentional or otherwise – sure to score “green” one! (pardon my Singlish)Follow us on Social Media

Send in your scoops to news@theindependent.sg 

No tags for this post.
- Advertisement -

MOH asks hospitals to delay non-urgent surgeries to conserve resources for Covid patients

Singapore— With Covid-19 cases rising, the Ministry of Health (MOH) asked hospitals on Monday (May 3) to delay non-urgent surgeries and give priority to the treatment of Covid patients. In a statement, MOH said it is "working closely with all public and...

5 KTPH staff disciplined for ‘error’ that led to unnecessary treatment of breast cancer patients 

Singapore—Five staff members of Khoo Teck Puat Hospital (KTPH) have been disciplined for a laboratory incident that led to inaccurate test results and unnecessary treatment for some breast cancer patients. The staff members were disciplined for "not adequately performing their duties and...

MOH confirms 17 new Covid-19 cases, five linked to Tan Tock Seng Hospital cluster

Singapore -- The Ministry of Health (MOH) has preliminarily confirmed five new cases of locally transmitted Covid-19 infection that are linked to the cluster at Tan Tock Seng Hospital (TTSH). Tuesday (May 4) also saw another 12 imported cases. It is the ninth...
Follow us on Social Media

Send in your scoops to news@theindependent.sg 

No tags for this post.