Home News Featured News Questions on the rise and rise of Singapore’s scholar-soldiers

Questions on the rise and rise of Singapore’s scholar-soldiers




- Advertisement -

By Augustine Low

The networks of power and influence in Singapore are complex but what is clear is that scholar-soldiers are now entrenched at the very apex. And this possibly marks the most dramatic change in the character of the national elite in the past 50 years.

This is among the conclusions drawn by Australian academic in his just-published book . Barr, an expert in international relations, has also written several books on , Singapore and regional politics.

Barr asserts that a central element of ’s social order was the transformation of the military into a scholar-dominated organisation. Lee Hsien Loong was the first scholar-soldier appointed to the Cabinet.

- Advertisement -

But how far we have come since then can be seen from the current Cabinet, which has numerous former military officers and :

  • PM Lee Hsien Loong
  • DPM Teo Chee Hean
  • Lim Hng Kiang
  • Lim Swee Say
  • Lui Tuck Yew
  • Chan Chun Sing
  • Tan Chuan-Jin

Besides the leading presence of the military in Cabinet, they also have numerical importance in the civil service, statutory boards and GLCs. Says Barr: “The military has, in a very real sense, provided a new cultural centre of gravity and a new standard for the elite.

Military officers are presumed to possess higher levels of organisational ability, self-discipline and leadership skills than others, and are routinely parachuted into critical leadership roles in both the administrative and political elite, both while on active duty and upon retirement.”

What conclusions of our own can we infer from the fact that scholar-soldiers are now nested at the very centre of the networks of power and influence in Singapore?

Firstly, it shows that the Singapore system celebrates and acknowledges scholar-soldiers as first among equals. It is the surest route to entry into the political and administrative elite.

Secondly, it suggests that all the training and grooming (especially mental and psychological) for our scholar-soldiers is geared towards a career and life among the ruling elite.

Thirdly, is it avoidable then to have group-think in the leadership? How diverse and robust can the leadership be if they largely come from the same mould, as the same products of the same system?

Fourthly, the scholar-soldier is essentially Chinese-dominated. Has there ever been a non-Chinese scholar-soldier who found his way into the political elite? How does such a system that produces purely Chinese scholar-soldiers to form , contribute to the national fabric of our society?

There may not be clear answers, but what remains undisputed is the rise and rise of the scholar-soldier to the current status as the centre of gravity and the gold standard for the elite in Singapore.

Please follow and like us:
- Advertisement -

Sexual harassment claim: NUS student says he did not receive proper help

Singapore -- A National University of Singapore (NUS) student, formerly from Tembusu College, has written a lengthy social media post not only about how he was sexually harassed by a former student tutor but also about how, when he tried to...

Biden will be nicer to China than Trump

Joseph Biden, the presumptive next US President, will be friendlier to China than US President Donald , judging by Biden’s statements and cabinet selections. Biden’s more harmonious posture towards China will please leaders of various Asian countries including Singapore Prime Minister...

K Shanmugam: In Singapore, the right to speak freely goes with the duty to act responsibly

Singapore—Speaking at the 16th Religious Rehabilitation Group Seminar at Khadijah Mosque on Monday (Nov 24), K Shanmugam, the Minister for Law and Home Affairs, said that the threat of terrorism has not gone away though its “shape and nature” have changed. Citing...
Please follow and like us:
Follow Me