Singapore — In a Facebook post on Sunday (Oct 3), businessman and former Nominated Member of Parliament Calvin Cheng explained why closing borders and pursuing a Covid-zero policy such as China and Hong Kong have done would be impossible for Singapore.
One reason why this is so is due to the Delta variant, whose transmissibility is higher than that of the original Covid strain, “unless very harsh measures are used,” wrote Mr Cheng.
Included in these measures would be strict border closures and tight local restrictions.
As Singapore’s priority is “to open to the rest of the world,” these restrictions would not work for Singapore’s good.
Mr Cheng explained why the country cannot follow the model of China, Hong Kong and even Taiwan, in managing the Covid pandemic, and why authorities announced some months ago to live with the virus and treat it as endemic.
The highly transmissible Delta virus has made living with Covid to be a challenge, however, with the rising number of new infections recorded daily despite Singapore’s high vaccination rate of over 82 per cent.
However, some people have questioned the decision to live with the virus, Mr Cheng wrote.
Singapore cannot be like China, since circumstances are very different. For China, “COVID was a blessing in disguise,” wrote the former NMP.
“China is huge and self-sufficient.
But I suspect that the decision to close up is also deliberate.
China’s growth was export-led, and they have been trying to grow domestic consumption.
COVID was a blessing in disguise.
When borders closed, the massive purchasing power was turned inwards. Domestic tourism is booming. F&B is booming. All manner of domestic consumption is booming.”
In other words, not only can China afford to hunker down, but the pandemic allowed it to “diversify away from an export-led economy, to one of domestic consumption.”
As for Hong Kong, Mr Cheng wrote that “Hong Kong is part of the PRC. That’s all there is. Their priority is to open to the motherland, not the rest of the world.”
But for trade-reliant and “too small” Singapore, conditions are very different. An economy based on domestic consumption is not possible.
“We have no choice but to live with the virus.
There is no other way.
So given this, we must minimise deaths, but still open,” he added, acknowledging that “… people will die. We, like all human being (sic) in the world, will get infected at some point in our lives.”
And people in China and Hong Kong will also get infected eventually, he added, “Because even mighty China cannot close their borders forever.” /TISG
“Singaporeans need clear instructions,” Calvin Cheng says government is making a mess of recovery