Home News Singapore retirement ranks high but adequacy is lagging

Singapore retirement ranks high but adequacy is lagging

Author

Date

Category

- Advertisement -

By: Chris Kuan

The annual Mercer Global Pension Index recently released showed that Singapore ranked 10th overall (the report provides the index scores by alphabetical order so I had to rank them myself). This looks good. Those ranked higher are the usual suspects: by ranking order Denmark, Netherlands, Australia, Sweden, Switzerland, Finland, Canada, Chile and the UK (Yes, that ‘collapsed state’ as mentioned by one of our Ministers.)
1Before, we all sigh in relief and the pro- fanboys and fangirls yelled “I told you so!”, the high rank does not mean Singapore is that highly ranked when it comes to that all important aspect – Adequacy which takes up 40% of the overall ranking and here Singapore fell to 19th behind even Brazil, China, Poland and Mexico.
1Now, do I recall Mr saying that our retirement adequacy is comparable or even better than to those in the first world countries when we unlock the value of our housing? This tells us where we stand on a like for like basis, i.e. not comparing apples to oranges. Those countries who are highly ranked overall are highly ranked in Adequacy as well.

In terms of Sustainability which is 35 percent of the overall index, Singapore is ranked at No. 8 for issues such as contributions, government debt, total assets and coverage with demography likely to hold back the score. This should not surprise because the level of contributions in Singapore is high and the government’s fiscal position is strong.

Although it will be difficult for Mercer to highlight the individual wrinkles, it should be noted that the government’s strong fiscal position is reliant to a significant extent on the drainage of those contributions via the medium of real estate prices. This should be born in mind.

- Advertisement -

In terms of Integrity which looks at such things as governance, protection and communication, Singapore is ranked 12.

In my opinion, there is a trade off between Adequacy and Sustainability. So it is important where we stand in the trade off. Given the large disparity between the two, quite clearly we have sacrificed Adequacy for Sustainability.

That is to say we have accepted (or are provided with comparatively inadequate payouts) in exchange for making the government finances stronger. After all there is a strong reason why Singapore is rated double Triple A. But as this survey shows and as I have repeatedly pointed out before – the very high credit rating comes at costs to our retirement adequacy and social benefits. Put in local parlance – ‘government rich, people poor’.

But here is the thing though – the trade off could be better for Adequacy without hurting Sustainability. Australia, Netherlands, Denmark, Sweden, Switzerland all scored higher than Singapore both in Adequacy and Sustainability. If we are talking about improving Adequacy by accepting lower Sustainability, Chile whose system is closest to Singapore (without the housing withdrawals), Finland and Canada provided better adequacy with sustainability not much below Singapore’s. Fruit for thought or if you rather, clearing the smoke.

Please follow and like us:
Tweet
Share
- Advertisement -

K Shanmugam: In Singapore, the right to speak freely goes with the duty to act responsibly

Singapore—Speaking at the 16th Religious Rehabilitation Group Seminar at Khadijah Mosque on Monday (Nov 24), K Shanmugam, the Minister for Law and Home Affairs, said that the threat of terrorism has not gone away though its “shape and nature” have changed. Citing...

Parliament receives 61 NMP proposal forms from the general public, groups

The Office of the Clerk of Parliament said yesterday (24 Nov) that Parliament has received 61 Nominated Member of Parliament (NMP) proposal forms. This is higher than the 48, 41 and 36 proposal forms that Parliament received in 2018, 2016 and...

No state acknowledgement for former President Yusof Ishak on his 50th death anniversary

Although 23 November 2020 marked half a century since Singapore's first President Yusof Ishak passed away, there was no state acknowledgement to commemorate the former President's 50th death anniversary. Neither current President Halimah Yacob, Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong nor any other...
Please follow and like us:
Tweet
Share
Follow Me
Tweet