Home News New fake news law not meant to have a chilling effect on...

New fake news law not meant to have a chilling effect on political discussions—Edwin Tong

The Minister of State for Law and Health said that the new bill will only encompass statements of fact and therefore, does not affect individuals who state their perspectives or beliefs




- Advertisement -

Singapore—“I don’t agree there’s a chilling effect,”  Minister of State for Law and Health Edwin Tong said regarding the possibility that the new bill meant to address the dissemination of online falsehoods will curb political discussions.

He said this at a forum at the Singapore Management University (SMU)’s Li Ka Shing library entitled “Truth and Lies: Trust in Times of Information ,” on Wednesday, April 3.

The Senior Minister of State for Law and Health sought to clarify the differences between falsehoods and merely airing opinions or criticism.

Mr Tong used the following example.

“If I say: ‘I think the government’s policies on the CPF are terrible,’ – that’s not a fact, that is a criticism. If I say: ‘The CPF account is bankrupt – the money is not there,’ and I published it and causes a panic amongst people. That’s a statement of fact.”

- Advertisement -

He responded to a question concerning whether the Protection from Online Falsehoods and Manipulation Bill could cause people to become cautious in discussions since they be uncertain as to whether what they say could be taken as a statement of fact that could be misleading or false.

Mr Tong said that the new bill will only encompass statements of fact and therefore, does not affect individuals who state their perspectives or beliefs.

The new bill gives ministers the discretion to act quickly against untruths online that are dangerous to public interest through ordering that corrections be made or that the content in question be taken down. However, individuals who disagree with this may contest this in court.

Mr Tong said that this is “not very different from how the Government might be expected to react if there was anything that affected the safety of our society. It might be physical safety, it might be from toxic gases, it might be from diseases. If we have basis to believe that public interest would be undermined, then the Government must make the first call.”

- Advertisement -

Another question arose concerning the breadth of the online audience that the bill applies to, and the Minister answered by saying that even in a small closed group on a messaging application such as WhatsApp, the bill applies whenever an individual makes a false statement of fact that undermines public interest.

“I don’t agree there’s a chilling effect. I do agree there must be more effort to draw the distinction between what’s a fact and a comment or opinion among the public when the law comes into effect.”

Mr Tong also talked about costs if and when someone desires to contest in court that the statement they made is actually when it’s been regarded false by a minister, since these costs are considerable.

He said there are provisions for legal assistance for those in need of them, but that the person contesting should prepare proof as to why they made the statements they did.

- Advertisement -

According to Mr Tong, “Those of us who need financial help, support or legal advice, systems are available in place to assist them…We are not talking about going to court on a complicated two-week or hearing that requires a lot of time and expense to deal with.”

The Minister also answered a question concerning what the consequences could be if the Government would deem a statement to be false and then the courts overturn this.

He said, “Obviously over time, if this keeps happening, then trust in the government will also be undermined. The government is not the one that stands outside of the system, without any (judicial) oversight.”

According to the new bill, those who are found in violation of it could be fined up to S$ 1 million, or face a ten-year jail sentence.-TISG

Read related: Human Rights Watch calls for “immediate withdrawal” of Singapore’s proposed fake news laws


 Follow us on Social Media

Send in your scoops to news@theindependent.sg 

- Advertisement -

S’porean woman, 83, dies from Covid-19 complications; Jurong Fishery Port cluster reaches 741

Singapore — An 83-year-old Singaporean woman has passed away from Covid-19 complications. She was not vaccinated against Covid-19, the Ministry of Health (MOH) reported on Saturday (Jul 24). The woman resided at Bukit Merah View and was linked to the 121 Bukit...

MAS’ Ravi Menon: Minimum wage can be considered to uplift those with lowest income

Singapore — The managing director of the Monetary Authority of Singapore floated the possibility of having a minimum wage to help those with the smallest incomes although he warned it would not do much to address income inequality. Speaking on the topic...

Covid-19: KTV cluster, Jurong Fishery Port outbreak and unvaccinated elderly are three missteps too many

Three missteps have brought Singapore to the current Phase Two Heightened Alert. As a result, Singaporeans are “biting the bullet” until three a half weeks later when it is unclear, at this stage, whether things will get much better. The most ridiculous...
Follow us on Social Media

Send in your scoops to news@theindependent.sg