New lawsuit filed against Keppel for Brazil bribery scandal

9823
 

By Koh Hui Xin

The Business Times and The Straits Times reported on Feb 11 and Feb 12 respectively that Keppel Corp said it has not yet been served with the court papers relating to a new racketeering lawsuit brought against Keppel Offshore & Marine (Keppel O&M) by certain funds managed by EIG Global Energy Partners in the United States.

Keppel was responding to a report published by legal news website Law360 on Feb 8, titled “EIG Hits Keppel With $660M RICO Suit Over Brazil Bribery”.

It is understood that the lawsuit was filed to the New York Southern Court on Tuesday, Feb 6, titled “EIG Energy Fund XIV, L.P. et al v. Keppel Offshore & Marine LTD.,”. The relevant court documents filed are available on Law360’s website.

The report stated that the EIG funds filed a $660 million racketeering suit against Keppel O&M over the latter’s role in a “Brazilian bribery scheme connected to a failed drill ship venture, for which Keppel recently reached a $422 million criminal settlement with U.S. prosecutors.”

RICO refers to the Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act, a United States federal law. Racketeering is the act of offering a racket. A racket, simply defined, is a planned or organised criminal act to earn illegal or extorted money.

In the RICO Act, racketeering includes a list of 35 crimes, including bribery, counterfeiting, theft, embezzlement, and fraud. A person who has committed at least two acts of racketeering activity within a 10-year period can be charged with racketeering. If convicted, those found guilty may serve up to 20 years in prison and/or be fined up to $25,000.

The RICO Act also permits a private individual “damaged in his business or property” by a “racketeer” to file a civil suit.

In the lawsuit filed by the EIG funds, it states that Keppel’s bribing of public officials at Petrobras and Brazilian politicians in order to win shipyard contracts with Petrobras and Sete has caused the funds to “lose the entirety of their $221 million investment in Sete”, and the funds’ “over US$221 million investment in Sete is now worthless”.

Law360 reported that “(w)hen the bribery reports first surfaced — as part of a sprawling investigation by Brazilian authorities involving Petrobras and politicians known as Operation Car Wash — other Sete lenders withdrew their funding, causing the company to default on its contracts and ultimately declare bankruptcy.”

The lawsuit states,

Keppel admitted that it ‘did knowingly and willfully conspire’ to violate the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act (the “FCPA”) through its participation in a long running bribery and kickback scheme. In the DPA, Keppel and its wholly-owned U.S. subsidiary agreed to pay a criminal penalty in the amount of US $422,216,980. Keppel’s admission in the DPA that it committed violations of the FCPA constitute an admission that it conspired to commit and did commit the RICO predicate acts of Travel Act violations and money laundering.

 

The DPA here refers to a Deferred Prosecution Agreement that Keppel reached with the U.S. Department of Justice on Dec 22, 2017, in which Keppel agreed to pay more than $422 million to resolve charges in the U.S., Brazil and Singapore that it paid millions of dollars in bribes to Brazilian officials.

The relevant parts of the lawsuit are reproduced below:

(Note: Plaintiffs refer to the EIG funds that filed this lawsuit)

Sete was created in 2011 by Petrobras for the sole purpose of raising outside capital on an “off balance sheet” basis, to fund the construction of twenty-eight offshore drillships at a cost of over US $700 million per driliship. The drillships were to be chartered by Sete to Petrobras for ten to twenty years, and the revenue from this chartering would be Sete’s sole source of income. Keppel, through subsidiaries, contracted with Sete to build six of the proposed drillships. The RICO conspiracy utilized Sete as a vehicle to expand an already existing massive bribery and kickback scheme. Keppel authorized and paid over US $14 million of bribes in the form of kickbacks to enrich senior executives at Petrobras, Sete and the Workers’ Party in return for being awarded six lucrative drillship contracts with Sete.
As Keppel well knew, in order for the bribery scheme to work, a critical and necessary component of the scheme was that Petrobras and Sete would fraudulently raise from third parties billions of dollars of capital for Sete, including from U.S. investors such as plaintiffs, without disclosing that the investors’ capital would actually finance millions of dollars of bribes and kickbacks. Without funding from outside investors, Sete could not pay Keppel for the construction of drillships and Keppel could not kick back a percentage of those payments as bribes.
Keppel facilitated Petrobras’ and Sete’s fraudulent fund raising activities. (…) At the times that Keppel met with EIG as representative of plaintiffs, Keppel had already agreed to pay millions of dollars in bribes and kickbacks to secure Sete drillship contracts. Keppel, in furtherance of the RICO conspiracy, did not at any time disclose to EIG or plaintiffs that Keppel secretly planned to and did pay millions of dollars of bribes and kickbacks relating to the Sete drillship contracts.
As a result of multiple RICO predicate acts committed by the RICO conspirators, from 2012 to early 2015, plaintiffs invested over US $221 million in Sete by wires emanating from banks in California and New York City. These investments were used to fund payments due under the corruptly obtained drillship contracts, a percentage of which was kicked back by Keppel in the form of bribes to senior executives of Petrobras and Sete and to the Workers Party.
In the DPA, Keppel admitted to knowingly and willfully conspiring to pay and paying bribes from 2001 to 2014 in connection with thirteen projects in Brazil tendered by Petrobras and Sete. The total bribes paid by Keppel over this time period amounted to approximately US $55 million, and were paid to Petrobras and Sete employees and the Workers’ Party. The bribes relating to Sete contracts totaled approximately US $14.4 million. Keppel further admitted that it and its subsidiaries earned profits totaling approximately US $351.8 million from the business Keppel obtained through its participation in the illicit scheme.

The lawsuit also detailed specific cases of Keppel’s involvement in apparent “bribery and kickback scheme” dating back to 2001.

The EIG funds are seeking redress against Keppel O&M for their lost investment, including treble damages under RICO of an amount no less than $663 million. Treble damages refer to tripling the amount of the compensatory damages to be awarded to the plaintiff. It is a mandatory provision in the RICO Act.

29 COMMENTS

  1. ****
    AHPETC supposedly got a S$30m overpayment issue that numerous auditors fr Auditor-General to KPMG went in but CANNOT CFM got criminal offence & yet we have Law Minister harping on it for few years with a superb charge of “unlawful activities”.
    Yet when US charged Keppel with its alleged S$60m bribery offense, i didnt read anything abt Law Minister rushing to CPIB & demanding Keppel CEO & major stakeholders be investigated to same extent like AHPETC (note the disparity in $$$ involved).
    Amazingly, there seem to be a new legislation (fr MinLaw) being rushed out to give such accused (like Keppel) some kind of legal protection/”subsidy”.
    PRC’s concept of “guanxi” is also practised here?
  2. EDIT 12.2.18. (NEWLY POSTED, PLS READ IT.)
    ===========

    TODAY, PRESIDENT TRUMP UNVEILS HIS $1.5 TRILLIONS INFRASTRUCTURE PLAN (EXPENSIVE, DIFFICULT AND GENERAL OFFER). “GENERAL” MEANS BOTH ECONOMIC AND POLITICAL MATTERS.

    FYI, LAST NIGHT, WHEN I OPENED MY LATE BROTHER’S ROOM DOOR, I STEPPED ONTO AN “OBJECT”(??) AND I SAW IT CRAWLING TOWARDS THE WARDROBE. I THEN TURNED ON THE LIGHT TO SEE WHAT WAS IT.

    OH, IT WAS A SMALL LIZARD (IN HOKKIEN, SIEN LANG REFERS TO ROTTON PAP) HIDING AT THE CORNER OF THE
    “WARDROBE” (STICKS TO SANGHA ROBES – MONKS AND NUNS ROBES, REMEMBER, I’M. A “SOLITARY HERO YAMANTAKA”!!)

    TODAY, THE RUSSIAN PLANE CRASHED, ALL DIED!!
    (CONFIRMED, “NO” TIMOTHY GO) (AND NO RUNNING, GOT INDIA)

    YESTERDAY, NEWS REPORTED BRITISH FM, BORIS JOHNSON, IS NOW ON A 4-DAY VISIT TO MYANMAR. HE MET AUNG SAN SUU KYI REQUESTING FOR AN “INDEPENDENT” PROBE INTO RAKHINE STATE.

    RECALLED
    =========

    I IMMEDIATELY RECALLED FEW WEEKS AGO WHAT I SAID:

    “DON’T EXPECT ME TO WORK “FOR” OR TO WORK “UNDER” THE ROTTON PAP MINISTERS AT ALL.”

    “WANT ME TO YIM SINGAPORE, TO YIM ASEAN, TO YIM ASIA, THEN I WANT TO REPLACE AND TO SUCCEED PM LHL AS THE NEXT PM OF SINGAPORE. OTHERWISE, DON’T EXPECT, OK! ”

    I FURTHER SAID THAT.”I DON’T WORK “UNDER” THEM (ROTTON PAP MINISTERS) BUT RATHER THEY HV TO COME AND WORK
    “UNDER MY FEET AND TAKE MY INSTRUCTIONS INSTEAD!”

    YESTERDAY (RE MY FB DATED 11.2.18), IN WHICH I AGAIN REITERATED MY STANCE THAT I WOULD NOT TAKE UP ANY JOBS IN SINGAPORE NOW AS I AM NOT INTERESTED TO WORK “UNDER” ANY OF CRONY PAP MINISTERS. I’M ALREADY ABOVE THEIR LEVELS.

    I SAID AS PM LHL IS “NOT” STEPPING DOWN YET TILL NEXT GE, SO I WOULD GO TO USA FIRST, IF USA REQUIRES ME.

    IF NOT, I WOULD GO TO INDIA INSTEAD TO HELP THE INDIAN GOVT DIRECT AND I WILL COME BACK TO SINGAPORE FOR THE NEXT ELECTION, READY TO REPLACE AND TO SUCCEED PM LHL, BE IT I JOIN PAP OR JOIN OPPO PARTY (CONSOLIDATED).

    #######

    NAH, YOU SEE THE SMALL LIZARD WAS “UNDER” MY FEET LAST NIGHT AT MY LATE BROTHER’S ROOM!!

    #######

    INDICATING THE ROTTON PAP TRULY WANTS ME AND NOW WANTS TO WORK WITH USA AND BRITAIN WITH ME, WHICH INDICATES THAT PAP AGREES THAT I WILL “REPLACE AND SUCCEED” PM LHL TO BE THE “NEXT PM OF SINGAPORE”!!

    OK, CONFIRM.

    ==================================+++=============

    GO TO USA FIRST, THEN RETURN TO SINGAPORE
    =========================================

    I HV YET TO RECEIVE ANY NOTICE FROM HDB CONTRACTOR FOR THE COMMENCEMENT OF MY TOILET RENOVATION.

    ONCE I’M READY, I WILL GO TO USA FIRST.

    THEN RETURN TO SINGAPORE BEFORE THE NEXT SINGAPORE GENERAL ELECTION, READY FOR THE BIG TASK!

    ========================================================

    10.2.18
    ======

    WEALTH CATS!!

  3. These class action suit against Keppel could burn a hole in the value of the company and given the likelihood of oil holding any price above $60 per barrel after OPEC agreement expires in coming year is seriously doubtful thus rig orders are not going anywhere soon. The darling of Singapore Stock market maybe down-down or possibly ‘wipe-out’ . Its ability to win new tenders ?????

  4. EIG and etc. had tried and failed in their initial suit. Keppel has again said it will defend its subsidiary vigorously. Worst case if Keppel will go down though Sgp MUST NOT as it is after all a limited liabilities company. So, touch NOT my CPF minimal sum that I HAD to leave in the CPF Fund. As a taxpayer, there is NO OBLIGATION for me to pay for a TLC’s folly. Yes? p/s: this is assuming the new EIG and etc. suit will be successful. Touch wood?