Home News Featured News M Ravi: Accused had simply intended to repeat allegations of PM Lee's...

M Ravi: Accused had simply intended to repeat allegations of PM Lee’s

All parties to return to the State Courts for pre-trial conference on Nov 19

Author

Date

Category

- Advertisement -

Singapore — In court on Friday (Oct 30), lawyer M Ravi argued that The Online Citizen () contributor Daniel De Costa was acting when he made allegedly defamatory statements.

Mr Ravi added that his client had simply intended to repeat what Hsien Loong’s siblings — Mr Lee Hsien Yang and Dr — had alleged in a joint statement in 2017. He argued that, under the law, those who express opinions about the conduct of public servants in good faith are not guilty of defamation.

Daniel De Costa and TOC editor Terry Xu were both charged with criminal defamation in for allegedly defaming members of the Singapore in a letter published on the TOC website.

“In our public statement on 14 June 2017, we wrote that Lee Hsien Loong opposed our father Lee Kuan Yew’s demolition wish, that Lee Hsien Loong misused his power as prime minister, and that he hijacked the organs of state to pursue his personal goals,” Mr Ravi quoted PM Lee’s siblings as having said, according to a straitstimes.com report on Friday (Oct 30).

- Advertisement -

The letter which De Costa wrote and Xu published alleged: “The present PAP leadership severely lacks innovation, vision and the drive to take us into the next lap.”

It added: “We have seen multiple policy and foreign screw-ups, tampering of the Constitution, corruption at the highest echelons and apparent lack of respect from foreign powers ever since the demise of Lee Kuan Yew.”

Mr Ravi added that Mr Lee Hsien Yang and Dr Lee were not sued by PM Lee, nor were they investigated for criminal defamation.

Mr Ravi put forth these arguments in the course of making an application to have the prosecution disclose De Costa’s long statement made to the Criminal Investigation Department during the police investigation in 2018.

He said he needed the long statement as it was “not clear what case the prosecution is running without these documents”.

On Friday, Xu’s lawyer, Mr Remy Choo of Peter Low and Choo law firm, made a similar application to have Xu’s recorded statement disclosed.
- Advertisement -

Mr Choo argued that the statement is relevant to the question of Xu’s intentions in publishing the letter and whether he deliberately published it knowing it would harm the reputation of Cabinet members.

He added that there was no reference to members of the Cabinet in the claim that there was “corruption at the highest echelons”, adding that an ordinary, reasonable reader of the article would not conclude that it refers to Cabinet members.

The applications were dismissed by the court.

The parties will return to the State Courts for a pre-trial conference on Nov 19 before the resumption of the trial. /TISG

TOC’s chief editor and one of its writers on trial for alleging corruption in Cabinet

- Advertisement -

Follow us on Social Media

Send in your scoops to news@theindependent.sg 

- Advertisement -

Nurse harassed by Sengkang neighbours granted protection order

Singapore — After being harassed by their neighbours for over a year, a Singaporean nurse has been granted an expedited protection order (EPO), providing him and his family “an overwhelming sense of relief.” Muhammad Najib bin Ngasewan, who works at Sengkang General...

Calvin Cheng asks people to stop blaming the government and foreigners for recent Covid-19 cluster

Singapore — In light of the recent KTV Covid-19 clusters that have cropped up in Singapore, former Nominated Member of Parliament (NMP) Calvin Cheng evaluated the factors leading to the spike in cases in a Facebook post he put up recently. He...

Jaguar F-Pace — The Delightful Big Cat

by Kannan Chandran www.storm-asia.com In the cabin of the Jaguar F-Pace there’s a little sign that reads “1935 Jaguar Coventry”. It’s a look back at history for a brand that had its roots in English motoring. But a lot has changed since, as...
Follow us on Social Media

Send in your scoops to news@theindependent.sg 

Theindependent