Singapore man's question: Does National Service give women an advantage in life?

Mika Guerra
|
3 m read
Singapore man's question: Does National Service give women an advantage in life?
(AI-generated image for illustrative purposes)

Does NS give women in Singapore a head start by allowing them to begin university or work earlier than men who are required to serve. (AI-generated image for illustrative purposes.)

SINGAPORE: What would you do with two years after you've finished school? You might go straight to a university; you might get a job; you might spend the time working and thinking about what you want to do. But for the young men in Singapore who have to do National Service, their plans have to be put on hold, as they have a responsibility that women don't have.

This led to a Reddit post asking whether women have it better than men in Singapore. The Redditor who started the discussion called this situation “silent misandry” and argued that women have an advantage in university and at work. In response, some people suggested that National Service should be open to women too, while others thought those who do not serve should contribute in other ways.

Should women be required to serve too?

One comment agreed that men carry an unequal burden but recalled an old thought about who is best suited to defend the country. They thought that seeing defence as a men's job also meant expecting them to put their plans on hold. They suggested making both men and women serve or just end compulsory service for everyone.

This emphasises what those two years really cost. If a man planned to go straight to university, he might have to start his degree later. If a man was ready to work, he might have to wait longer to earn a full-time salary. The main idea is that women have more control when they make these choices.

Could a security tax share the burden?

While one commenter suggested expanding who has to serve, another proposed a financial contribution from citizens who don’t serve. Under the proposed security tax, those who serve would be exempt. The commenter also suggested that women could volunteer for National Service or qualify for a tax refund if they had children.

The proposal raises two questions. If some citizens spend their time on national defence, is it fair to ask others to pay money? And if the goal is to give people more options on how they contribute, what will happen if part of a woman’s tax bill depends on whether she has children?

Why the debate went beyond National Service

The post author also mentioned spousal support after divorce and the legal meaning of rape. The first commenter noticed a link to the ideas behind “men-only” military service. Men are expected to protect and provide, while women are expected to take care of children and are more often seen as victims. In that view, traditional gender roles can limit women’s options while putting responsibilities on men.

National Service highlights the trade-off in a clear way. People’s responses to the Reddit post suggest different ways to share the responsibility, such as expanding compulsory service or having those who don’t serve contribute financially. Any proposal needs to answer the original question: Who should be asked to pause their plans for national defence, and why?

Two classmates can finish school on the same day and have the same plans. If both get a job offer, she can decide whether to take it. If he’s called up for National Service, he has to plan around two years of full-time service. By the time he’s ready to start, the job might no longer be available. In the Reddit discussion, some thought more people should be asked to serve. Others suggested that those who don’t serve should contribute financially instead. Both ideas bring the debate back to those two classmates. When national defence depends on someone putting their plans on hold, how should Singapore decide whose plans have to wait?

Newsletter

Get updates straight to your inbox