Home News Writer asks: By 's logic, aren't voters free riders, too?

Writer asks: By PM Lee’s logic, aren’t PAP voters free riders, too?

: The term refers to people who do not vote when voting is optional

Author

Date

Category

- Advertisement -

Singapore — Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong’s remarks in Parliament earlier this week about free riders have ruffled more than a few feathers.

On Wednesday (Sept 2), he referred to Singaporeans who voted for the opposition while expecting the People’s Action Party () to remain in power as “free riders”.

“But if you say, vote for for me, somebody else will vote for the PAP, and therefore the PAP will be the Government, that, the economists will call a . It means that you’re taking advantage of somebody else who’s doing their duty of electing a government for the nation,” Mr Lee said.

Workers’ Party (WP) head and Leader of the Opposition responded by saying: “I don’t think the residents of Aljunied, Hougang for 30 years now, and even Sengkang, as a result of the results of the last election, would appreciate being called free riders.”

- Advertisement -

WP MP , an associate professor of , voiced his view in a Facebook post, explaining that a is “an individual (or group) that reaps the benefits of the actions of others, without paying the cost (or underpaying for it)”.

He wrote that the term is used in to describe “a form of market failure, and characterises non-excludable goods (those whose use cannot be restricted)”.

What voters did in Aljunied, Hougang and Sengkang did not strike him “as consistent with free riding”, adding, “they voted with their hearts, and with the conviction that some alternative voices were needed. Sure, they did so with some reassurance that the PAP would likely continue to form government. But it certainly wasn’t because they were looking for a free ride”.

Writer has also weighed in on the issue and, like A/Prof Lim, has tackled it from the point of view of economics.

- Advertisement -

Mr Vadaketh wrote: “There is really only one scenario when economists use the concept of ‘free riders’ in the context of voting behaviour: When describing people who choose not to vote in democracies where voting is optional, such as the US.”

This, he added, does not apply to Singapore, since voting is compulsory.

“Lee is the first person I’ve heard use the term ‘free rider’ on people who actually show up to vote…. In other words, Lee’s description of what ‘the economists will call a free rider’ is just plain wrong. I have never heard an economist use free rider in that way.”

Moreover, Mr Vadaketh asked that, if the Prime Minister’s logic were to be followed, would this not make voters for the PAP free riders as well?

- Advertisement -

Pointing out that many of the PAP’s supporters are against the idea of the party controlling the entire government, believing that this type of monopoly is not good for Singapore, he wrote “allow me to replicate Lee’s inelegant co-option of an economic concept, and let’s go along with his logic”.

“If indeed there are opposition ‘free riders’, aren’t there also PAP free riders? 

By Lee’s logic, aren’t PAP voters who want an opposition presence in Parliament actually free riding on the voters of Aljunied, Hougang and Sengkang?”

Calling Mr Lee’s statement about “free riders” “an awful thing for a country’s leader to say about its voters”, Mr Vadaketh listed five reasons why he believed this is so, which may be found in full here. /TISG

Read also: Ho Ching on PM Lee-Pritam Singh debate: A free rider is not a free loader

Ho Ching on PM Lee-Pritam Singh debate: A free rider is not a free loader

 Follow us on Social Media

Send in your scoops to news@theindependent.sg 

- Advertisement -

Suspected Ang Mo Kio cat-slasher arrested

Singapore – A 37-year-old man has been arrested for his suspected involvement in a series of cat-slashing incidents in Ang Mo Kio. The Animal & Veterinary Service (AVS), an entity under the National Parks Board (NParks), conducted an operation on Tuesday (June...

Circles.Life telco comes under fire for ad that implies hierarchy between Chinese, Malays and Filipinos; company does not apologise

Update In an update, Circles.Life Singapore issued an apology on their Instagram page on Thursday (Jun 10).   View this post on Instagram   A post shared by Circles.Life (@circleslifesg) Delbert Stanley Ty, Head of Marketing also added: “We messed up. We’re sorry. Our posts were tone...

‘Badge Lady’ asks that charges against her be dropped, claims there were ‘errors’ in the investigation

Singapore — Phoon Chiu Yoke, or "Badge Lady" as she is called by netizens, has been released on S$8,000 bail after she was remanded at the Institute of Mental Health (IMH) for two weeks. The 53-year-old was infamously caught on camera refusing...
Follow us on Social Media

Send in your scoops to news@theindependent.sg 

Theindependent