Home News Man fined $1,000 for defacing PAP poster blames stress and his “own...

Man fined $1,000 for defacing PAP poster blames stress and his “own stupidity”

Judge says clear message needed that defacing and destroying election posters is 'utterly unacceptable'




- Advertisement -

Singapore—A man has been fined for defacing a People’s Action Party (PAP) campaign poster in last July’s General Election in the first such case.

Lim Song Huat, 48, was fined $1000 for the offence on Thursday (Feb 4).

He could also have been jailed up to one year.

Lim said in mitigation that he had not originally intended to deface only the PAP posters, one of which bore the image of Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong.

- Advertisement -

He had also wanted to reach the Singapore Democratic Party (SDP) poster above the PAP poster, but could not.

The part-time security guard pleaded guilty to one charge of defacing an election poster under the Parliamentary Elections (Election Advertising) Regulations.

Two other similar charges were taken into consideration.

He said that stress and his own “stupidity” were the cause of his imprudent behavior.

The incident occurred on the morning of July 3, 2020.

Lim left his home in Woodlands earlier that day and bought some 4D tickets.

On his way home, he saw PAP posters under SDP posters along the service road of Woodlands Street 13, behind Marsiling Secondary School.

He then took a stone and tried to use it to tear up the PAP poster with PM Lee’s picture. When he failed to rip it with the stone, he tore down over half of the poster with his own hands.

He also tore another PAP poster, and took a black pen and marked a third one with a horizontal line.

A report was lodged with the police on July 4 about the defaced posters. Lim, who was caught in the act on CCTV cameras, was arrested.

According to Deputy Public Prosecutor Selene Yap, the posters cost $10 each.

She told the court that the offences were “incredibly hard to detect” because the posters were placed in public spaces all across the country. Lim should be given the maximum fine of $1000, she said.

CNA quotes the DPP as saying to District Judge Marvin Bay, “As your honour is well aware, election campaigns are highly regulated in Singapore. It takes place over a short period of time, and putting up of posters in public places is highly regulated. There is a limit to the amount of posters parties can put up, and the time they can put it up for.”

She added that defacing the posters “deprives candidates of the ability to present themselves to the electorate”.

Lim said it was his first offence and asked for a lighter sentence.

He told the court, ”Because of stupidity (and) influence of my colleague, that’s why I do this stupid thing.”

He said he had emailed the PAP a request to do volunteer work.

Asked by the judge why he was stressed, he replied that he had become frustrated, feeling things do not change in the country, no matter who is voted into office.

“You know whether it’s PAP, SDP, Workers’ Party, we don’t have the talented people there. So sometimes, as a member of public, we are worrying that maybe in two years’ time, five years’ time, what will happen to Singapore to progress. So, sometimes out of frustration, you want to pour out the frustration, that’s why.”

However, he added that the MPs where he lives “have done a good job,” installing “a lot of facilities”.

“I’m not only against PAP. It’s because of frustration. The voice in my head — my colleague (said)  — you want to vote PAP or SDP,” he added.

But Judge Bay said that it was important for the court to send a clear message that destroying or defacing election posters is “utterly unacceptable,” given that this is the first case prosecuted under a particular segment of the Parliamentary Elections Act.

He said, “While a person might hold strong political views, this should be expressed through their votes at the ballot box or by other legally sanctioned means.”


Read also: Two men charged with defacing or removing and destroying PAP, PSP election posters

Two men charged with defacing or removing and destroying PAP, PSP election posters

Send in your scoop to news@theindependent.sg 

- Advertisement -

Man attacks teen, calls him a virus, damages his phone

Singapore—A sudden attack took a teen by surprise when one man started yelling at him, physically harming him, and throwing his phone into a nearby drain at around 10.30pm on Tuesday (Feb 23) on a section of the road near the...

3 migrant workers die after 10 injured in Tuas industrial building blast

Singapore – Three of the 10 workers injured in an explosion at an industrial building in Tuas on Wednesday (Feb 24) died on Thursday. The Singapore Civil Defence Force (SCDF) responded to a fire at No. 32E Tuas Avenue 11 at around...

Film producer says Myanmar maid called her family, wanting to go home, two weeks before she died

A video producer who visited the family of Piang Ngaih Don, the Myanmar maid beaten and starved to death by her employers in 2016, says Ms Piang somehow managed to call her family just two weeks before she died. She told...

Send in your scoop to news@theindependent.sg