Home News Featured News should only be for clear cut cases of falsehoods, not for...

POFMA should only be for clear cut cases of falsehoods, not for interpretations of statistical data, says

Secretary-General of the SDP Dr and Vice-Chairman took to Facebook to express their disagreement on Justice Ang Cheng Hock's ruling which said that the statements were “false in the face of the statistical evidence against them”

Author

Date

Category

- Advertisement -

Secretary-General of the () Dr and Vice-Chairman both took to social media reiterating the arguments they presented in court despite an unfavourable ruling.

On Wednesday (Feb 5), the High Court dismissed the SDP’s appeal to set aside Correction Directions issued against it under the Protection from Online Falsehoods and Manipulation Act ().

Calling the party’s statements “false in the face of the statistical evidence against them”, Justice Ang Cheng Hock, said that it had not challenged the accuracy of the Ministry of Manpower’s () statistics, but instead “sought to critique it on other grounds” that he did not find convincing.

Despite this ruling, both Secretary-General and Vice-Chairman took to social media to comment.

- Advertisement -

In his Facebook post on that day, Dr Chee wrote: “We are, of course, very disappointed with the verdict”.

He added: “We note, however, that the Judge had written that the role of the court in this context is to interpret the legislation and “In that sense, the Court is constrained by what the legislation compels.”

We also note that the Judge had pointed out that “Unlike the Minister, who is able to rely on the machinery of the state to procure the relevant evidence of falsity, the maker of a statement often has to contend with far more limited resources”.

Not backing down, Dr Chee wrote: “We reiterate our case which we argued in Court: POFMA must only be applied to clear cut cases of falsehoods, not for interpretations of statistical data”.

He also concluded his Facebook post stating that the party was considering appealing the decision.

Similarly, in another Facebook post, Mr Tan wrote that he “studied statistics for about 10 years and taught it for another 20 years. But the judge, who is not trained in statistics (he might have taken a course or two while in school), can simply dismiss my arguments as “false in the face of statistical evidence.””

He added: “I should have studied law… because then, you can judge anything under the sun, including a complex subject such as statistics, even if you haven’t studied it”.

What initially happened

On Dec 2, the SDP published a sponsored Facebook post with a graphic showing plunging local PMET employment.

Refuting the SDP’s statement that local PMET retrenchment was rising, the Ministry of Manpower said the number of retrenched local PMETs had declined since 2015. It also said that the graphic the SDP published was wrong and that the ministry’s Comprehensive Labour Force Survey showed that local PMET employment had risen steadily since 2015.

On Dec 16, while the SDP complied with the Pofma Correction Directions and posted correction notices on its article and earlier Facebook posts, it said that the conclusions that Manpower Minister had come to were “disputable”.

On Jan 3, the SDP applied to the ministry to have the corrections cancelled, which Mrs Teo rejected.

The SDP then filed its court challenge on Jan 8. /TISG

Read related: Judge dismisses SDP’s Pofma appeal relating to local PMET employment statistics

Please follow and like us:
Tweet
Share
- Advertisement -

Raeesah Khan mingles with Alfian Sa’at, Ivan Heng at local theatre show

Workers' Party (WP) MP Raeesah Khan mingled with noted theatre professionals Alfian Sa'at, Ivan Heng and Siti Khalijah Zainal as she caught one of the last shows of W!LD RICE's 'An Actress Prepares'. 'An Actress Prepares' stars Siti, who plays herself, and...

Goh Chok Tong undergoes laser surgery to remove large kidney stone

Former Singapore Prime Minister Goh Chok Tong underwent laser surgery over the weekend to remove a kidney stone that was somewhat large in size. 79-year-old Mr Goh has been frank on social media about the health issues he faces. On Sunday (22...

PM Lee’s nephew Li Shengwu calls on him to resign now

Singapore -- Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong's nephew Li Shengwu has called on him to  resign now as Prime Minister, in the latest turn of the Lee family feud. Mr Li Shengwu made the call on Friday (Nov 20), the same day...
Please follow and like us:
Tweet
Share
Follow Me
Tweet