Home News Defence lawyer in acquitted maid case, “We had to convince the judge,...

Defence lawyer in acquitted maid case, “We had to convince the judge, look, why would someone steal junk?”

Additionally, he said that Ms Parti did not have a "robust defence,” in terms of photographic evidence to prove that the items she had been accused of stealing were, in fact, hers

Author

Date

Category

- Advertisement -

Singapore—In a video interview, , the lawyer of acquitted domestic helper , talked about the uphill battle he faced in mounting her defence.

The video, taken on August 23, was uploaded on September 9 (Wednesday) on YouTube by Humanitarian Organisation for Migration Economics (), a Non-Government Organization that advocates for in Singapore.

Ms Parti worked for Mr and his family from 2007 until 2016. Mr Liew was, until Thursday (September 10), the Chairman of the Changi Airport Group (). On March 20, 2019, District Judge Olivia Low found Ms Parti guilty of four counts of theft. She was sentenced to 26 months in jail for allegedly stealing more than S$34,000 worth of goods from the Liew family.

- Advertisement -

Ms Parti, 46, appealed against conviction and was successfully represented by Mr of Red Lion Circle Advocates and Solicitors. He had submitted that she had been framed by her employers in order to prevent her from filing a complaint of illegal deployment.

Last Friday (September 4) Judge Chan Seng Onn, in his ruling to acquit Ms Parti, pointed out the problematic nature in which the case was investigated.

Mr Balchandani, whom HOME approached for a pro-bono defence of Ms Parti, clearly outlined the hardships in the helper’s case, calling the trial, which lasted 10 months, a “very, very difficult” one.

This was because of the “the sheer number of items that we had to deal with” adding that Ms Parti and her defence team had to contend with “a very tenacious set of prosecutors”, as well as “a very prominent family”.

Additionally, he said that Ms Parti did not have a “robust defence,” in terms of photographic evidence to prove that the items she had been accused of stealing were, in fact, hers.

“One of the downsides of our case was that Parti… never really took a lot of photographs of herself, to identify, look… I had these items, I bought these items, I shared these photographs with whoever it was.”

But he was grateful that the defence had been allowed to present before the appellate court the said items, so that it would be obvious that these were neither new nor in the best condition, such as the outdated jewellery or old DVD player.

Had the court only allowed photographs, this would not have been so obvious, he said.

“Each item had to be explained. The prosecution had its own side to the story, and we had to basically convince a judge that, look, why would someone steal junk?”

The lawyer expressed admiration for Ms Parti’s determination to see her name cleared, when so many others in a similar situation would have chosen to simply plead guilty. If she had done so, said Mr Balchandani, she would have been back home in Indonesia by now, instead of being stuck in Singapore, unable to work for nearly four years.

He said of Ms Patti, ”She could have restarted her life, continued working in another country and just thought about what happened in October 2016 (as just a bad dream).”

As for the organization that gave her aid, the lawyer said they also deserved praise.

“The bulk of the work is really done by a lot of people from Home and the other NGOs that step forward… the back-breaking activity (of) meeting with (those they are helping) every week, every month, giving them that hope that something good can happen.” —/TISG

Read also: CAG chairman Liew Mun Leong retires early after court acquits ex-maid Parti Liyani in stealing case

CAG chairman Liew Mun Leong retires early after court acquits ex-maid Parti Liyani in stealing case

Please follow and like us:
Tweet
Share
- Advertisement -

Sexual harassment claim: NUS student says he did not receive proper help

Singapore -- A National University of Singapore (NUS) student, formerly from Tembusu College, has written a lengthy social media post not only about how he was sexually harassed by a former student tutor but also about how, when he tried to...

Biden will be nicer to China than Trump

Joseph Biden, the presumptive next US President, will be friendlier to China than US President Donald Trump, judging by Biden’s statements and cabinet selections. Biden’s more harmonious posture towards China will please leaders of various Asian countries including Singapore Prime Minister...

K Shanmugam: In Singapore, the right to speak freely goes with the duty to act responsibly

Singapore—Speaking at the 16th Religious Rehabilitation Group Seminar at Khadijah Mosque on Monday (Nov 24), K Shanmugam, the Minister for Law and Home Affairs, said that the threat of terrorism has not gone away though its “shape and nature” have changed. Citing...
Please follow and like us:
Tweet
Share
Follow Me
Tweet