Home News Wearable tracking devices are cause for concern: Singapore People's Party

Wearable tracking devices are cause for concern: Singapore People’s Party

Opposition party mentions incidents in 2018 and 2019 when information online was easily stolen




- Advertisement -

Singapore — The Government’s move to issue the people with wearable contact tracing devices was described as a cause for concern on Sunday (June 7) by the opposition Singapore People’s Party (SPP).

Dr Vivian Balakrishnan, Minister for Foreign Affairs and Minister-in-charge of the Smart Nation Initiative, had announced on June 5 that a wearable device for contact tracing may be issued to the people in a bid to contain the spread of Covid-19.

He explained that technical difficulties with the contact tracing app, TraceTogether, have been limiting its effectiveness. He said: “The app does not appear to work as well on iOS or Apple devices.”

Using Bluetooth technology, TraceTogether tracks nearby phones with the app. In this way, the app helps identify anyone in close contact with an infected individual. The problem,  however, according to Dr Balakrishnan, is that Apple devices suspend the use of Bluetooth scanning when the app is running in the background. This technical difficulty is the main reason why the state has not called for the mandatory use of TraceTogether.

- Advertisement -

To date, it is said that approximately 1.5 million users have downloaded TraceTogether, or  only about 25% of the population.

In a bid to accelerate contact tracing, Dr Balakrishnan proposed wearable contact tracing devices to make up for the inefficiency of TraceTogether. This has since sparked a public outcry over data privacy.

SPP Reacts

The SPP condemned this proposed initiative in a statement on Sunday (June 7), arguing that “the mere fact that a pandemic exists does not amount to a blank cheque to allow for unwarranted intrusion into seclusions”.

The party especially highlighted concerns over collection of private data and mentioned incidents in 2018 and 2019 when information online was easily stolen.

The party also highlighted the common narrative adopted to not oppose government surveillance, that one should not fear if they have nothing to hide, “is riddled with fallacies”. Wearable devices are deemed as infringing on fundamental, individual rights.

Ultimately, SPP believes that such “drastic and draconian measures” which are seen as “extraordinary measures”, “do require extraordinary evidence and justification” by the state.

Many of those commenting on the post shared SPP’s sentiments on the matter.

Local artiste Hossan Leong, also commenting on Dr Balakrishnan’s Facebook post, stated  that “wearing a device is one step too far”.

Currently, there is also a petition against the wearable device on change.org initiated by Wilson Low. He wrote that such a move takes Singapore one step closer to “sealing our fate as a police state”.

Privacy – An issue for the coming GE?

Over the years, concerns over data privacy have been on the rise in the country. The data breaches mentioned earlier have cast doubt on the ability of the state to safeguard data stored online and protect the privacy of the individual.

The proposal on the use of wearable contract tracing devices has exacerbated these concerns and has blurred the lines between individual privacy and public good even further – contributing to greater public dissent.

Dr Balakrishnan has reaffirmed that this wearable contact tracing device “is NOT a tracking device … our contract tracing app and device does NOT track location”. He adds that “we believe we are actually being far more protective of privacy than in many other jurisdictions”.

Increasing divisiveness over public good and individual right, especially in light of the pandemic, may set the stage for the issue of privacy to be prominent in the coming elections. /TISG





 Follow us on Social Media

Send in your scoops to news@theindependent.sg 

No tags for this post.
- Advertisement -

Leong Sze Hian faces backlash for crowdfunding, shares hate messages he received

  Singapore — Some of the wind has gone out of blogger Leong Sze Hian's crowdfunding campaign and he has been getting hate messages too. Mr Leong took only 11 days to raise the S$133,000 the High Court ordered him to pay as...

M’sian worker and sole breadwinner suffers a stroke and severe memory loss in SG; family with two young kids crowdfunds for S$100K

Singapore -- A 34-year-old Malaysian man who was working in Singapore lost his memory after collapsing from a stroke. He is the sole breadwinner for his family, and his wife and two young children are crowdfunding to pay his medical bills. In...

Just close the borders: netizens on the stricter measures amid rising Covid-19 cases

Singapore – With the recent announcement of stricter measures amid a rise in community cases within Singapore, social media is abuzz with netizens going back to border controls, noting these might have prevented such a scenario. The Ministry of Health (MOH) announced...
Follow us on Social Media

Send in your scoops to news@theindependent.sg 

No tags for this post.