Home News National Youth Council under fire for plagiarism of programme concept and its...

National Youth Council under fire for plagiarism of programme concept and its poor facilitation

Follow us on Instagram and Telegram
- Advertisement -

By Phyllis Lee

Singapore’s National Youth Council (NYC) was accused of plagiarising Drama Box, a non-profit contemporary Chinese language theatre company, over the former’s programme titled ‘For Your Consideration’ held last Monday (4 September).

The public engagement programme had emulated the concept behind Drama Box’s interactive play, ‘The Lesson’, held in July.

‘For Your Consideration’ took on a similar structure and approach as ‘The Lesson’, getting the audience to participate in a group decision-making discussion based on a given scenario.

Last Wednesday (6 August), Chief Executive Officer of NYC David Chua posted an apology to Drama Box on his Facebook account.

Whilst the apology was accepted by Drama Box’s artistic director Kok Heng Leun, he also said that NYC’s programme only perpetuated the discrimination of different groups in Singapore.

The programme put youth participants into a scenario where only three out of four families would be given a space in a new estate due to the lack of space. The families are:

1. Farah – Single parent with 2 kids

2. Grace – Single but married with same sex partner overseas, returned to SG with the hope of adopting a child and starting a family here

3. Ah Biao – Single Elderly

4. Janice – Just married without kids; just graduated and started working

The audience had to come to a consensus to choose one of the four families to be voted out.

Interestingly, these participants had quite a lot to say about their experiences. Ms Serene Ho replied to Mr Chua’s apology post, saying that she felt unsafe when she expressed her “differing opinion that a homosexual couple does not form a family unit”.

She claimed that she was booed at, and that the event was overrun by lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender (LGBT) activists.

Netizen Leo Hee Khian, whose friends had participated in the programme, said that its set-up was poorly designed. He argued that most participants only wanted to voice their own opinions, turning a deaf ear to those who opposed them.

On the other hand, freelance journalist and activist Kirsten Han, who also attended the event, said that the dialogue was civil and free for all to give their own input.

Participant Hum Qing Ze agreed, saying that everyone had an opportunity to speak. He concluded that such dialogue is necessary for societal discourse, and that the facilitation of similar programmes will eventually improve. 

Follow us on Social Media

Send in your scoops to news@theindependent.sg 

- Advertisement -
Follow us on Instagram and Telegram

Read More

Mercedes hit and run at multi-storey carpark, detaches bumper from parked car

Imagine going back to your parked cark only to discover the front bumper detached in a hit-and-run accident. A black Mercedes was caught on camera damaging a vehicle at a multi-storey carpark and promptly leaving the scene. Community page Complaint Singapore...

How Much Will Owning A Cat Cost You?

Owning a pet is the new trend these days; pets have become more than just pets. Pets are our friend, family member and someone...

Happy 57th birthday, Singapore: 10 predictions for next 57 years

Singapore celebrates its 57 years of independence on Tuesday Aug 9. PM Lee Hsien Loong will probably spell out some of the challenges confronting...

MMA fighter pins down serial attacker with ease, ‘jiu-jitsu instincts just kicked in’

Filipino-American mixed martial artist (MMA) Ro Malabanan was on his way to work in New York when he witnessed a man getting sucker punched...

Shaming photo backfires as netizens defend woman who ‘needs 4 seats’ on bus

Sometimes tables turn against people who appear to go out of their way to shame someone publicly by posting a photo of them over...

Mercedes hit and run at multi-storey carpark, detaches bumper from parked car

Imagine going back to your parked cark only to discover the front bumper detached in a hit-and-run accident. A black...

How Much Will Owning A Cat Cost You?

Owning a pet is the new trend these days; pets have become more than just pets. Pets are our...

Happy 57th birthday, Singapore: 10 predictions for next 57 years

Singapore celebrates its 57 years of independence on Tuesday Aug 9. PM Lee Hsien Loong will probably spell out...

MMA fighter pins down serial attacker with ease, ‘jiu-jitsu instincts just kicked in’

Filipino-American mixed martial artist (MMA) Ro Malabanan was on his way to work in New York when he witnessed...
Follow us on Social Media

Send in your scoops to news@theindependent.sg