Home News Activist Kirsten Han explains why Singapore is not the next Hong Kong

Activist Kirsten Han explains why Singapore is not the next Hong Kong




- Advertisement -

Singapore—Despite frequent comparisons between Singapore and Hong Kong due to their inherent similarities, one activist writes about why Singapore will not follow in Hong Kong’s footsteps, which were marked this year by increasingly widespread and violent protests over the last six months.

While Singapore has benefited economically from the turmoil in Hong Kong—in terms of investments and hotel occupancy rates, fears of Singaporeans erupting in similar protests have also made the rounds. Civil disquiet in a particular country is, after all, not unknown to spread in neighboring ones.

Activist Kirsten Han, who, in an article for foreignpolicy.com, says that during a visit to Hong Kong earlier this year she thought that the media in Hong Kong would end up becoming more like Singapore’s—that is, under the strict control of the government.

Moreover, she quotes a senior official telling the Financial Times that the PAP government “is terrified that something similar could happen in Singapore,” to the point of making contingency plans should this come to pass, something Ms Han calls “a bizarre fear”.

- Advertisement -

The primary reason for this is that Singapore does not suffer from the same political crisis as Hong Kong does. Ms Han explains, “At the heart of Hong Kong’s struggle is the disenfranchisement of its people. The political process is explicitly rigged—a reality starkly demonstrated by the disqualification of both political candidates and elected pro-democracy legislators in this month’s local elections.”

This is not true of Singapore, where its citizens are still able to make wishes known through casting their ballots. “While the fairness of the electoral system leaves much to be desired, there is still universal suffrage, and Singaporeans do still have the opportunity to make their feelings known at the ballot box,” Ms Han writes.

Furthermore, the PAP has enjoyed popular support and will most likely continue to do so. “Many continue to credit the ruling party with Singapore’s stability and solid international reputation, and the provision of more social welfare schemes ahead of the 2015 election is likely to have calmed frustrations over cost of living.”

Ms Han also points out the vast difference in how resistance and dissent are viewed in Hong Kong and Singapore. In Hong Kong, protests have become a part of tradition, whereas, in Singapore, the stringency of laws makes organizing acts of resistance extremely challenging. She cites the case of the pro-establishment restauranteur from Hong Kong who was repatriated after holding an assembly for citizens from Hong Kong last month. This restauranteur will not be allowed to re-enter Singapore without express permission from immigration.

Ms Han ends her article by emphasizing how the turmoil in Hong Kong can actually be used to the advantage of the ruling party, since its prevailing message is to value stability above all else, to the detriment of Singapore’s own pro-democracy activists.

She quotes PAP stalwarts such as Education Minister Ong Ye Kung, Trade and Industry Minister Chan Chun Sing, and even former PAP MP Goh Choon Kang, who have all, in different ways and occasions, issued warnings over what may happen to Singapore or pointed to what lessons Singapore can learn from Hong Kong’s present troubles, which are aimed at making Singaporeans fearful of political contagion.

She writes, “Over the years, the Singaporean political discourse has been skewed to value stability above almost everything else. The Hong Kong protests offer the PAP the opportunity to again perpetuate a siege mentality, prompting anxiety about the country’s supposed fragility in the face of any political shake-up. Talk of fears of contagion is thus more about political mileage than any immediate danger.” -/TISG

Read related: Sweeping victory for pro-democracy candidates in Hong Kong

Sweeping victory for pro-democracy candidates in Hong Kong

 Follow us on Social Media

Send in your scoops to news@theindependent.sg 

- Advertisement -

Calvin Cheng cautions: “The PAP needs to remember how to be a political party”

Singapore -- Former Nominated Member of Parliament (NMP) Calvin Cheng took to social media to say that the era of Lee Kuan Yew-style politics was over. In a Facebook post on Tuesday (Apr 13), Mr Cheng wrote about politics in Singapore. “For half...

Those who recover from Covid-19 may be at risk for blood clotting: S’pore study

Singapore – According to a study by the Nanyang Technological University (NTU), people who have recovered from Covid-19 may face risks of blood clot formation due to an overactive immune response. Covid-19 patients, especially those with pre-existing cardiovascular conditions, may be at...

Tan Cheng Bock and Goh Chok Tong were apparently from the same CCA in RI

Singapore -- Known to have been close friends once, Dr Tan Cheng Bock and Mr Goh Chok Tong recently attended the same scouting event at Raffles Institution, indicating that they were likely from the same CCA as well. In a Facebook post...
Follow us on Social Media

Send in your scoops to news@theindependent.sg