Home News Featured News Vandalism and political defiance

Vandalism and political defiance




- Advertisement -

By Trinity Chua and Tan Yong Heng

Defiance and dissent is taking on a slightly violent streak. Vandals have struck by scrawling anti-PAP words on top of a Toa Payoh block of flats, painting on the war monument and attacking posters at bus stops.

We spoke to a lawyer, sociologist and a political science lecturer for their views. Is there something more than meets the eye, we asked sociologist Chua Beng Huat.

He warned about over reading into these incidents. “There are always more ‘deviants’ than there are police; the likelihood of  ‘crime’ being solved is generally low in every society. Also, they are willing to take their chances for their commitment or pleasure,” said Chua.

- Advertisement -

Still, others were worried that isolated or not, vandalism was part of a show of defiance following the lifting of a less authoritarian political climate.

It may not be clear to some that vandaslism is a criminal act – willful destruction of public property –  which carries the painful punishment of three to eight strokes of the cane. Not to mention the social stigma which will destroy one’s career. Plus, for a number of its ex-perpetrators, a psychological scar they may bear for the rest of their lives.

For example, ex-vandalism offender American youth Michael Fay, 18, returned home and could not adjust to a normal life. In Singapore, he was found guilty of theft and the vandalising of a number of cars and was jailed four months and given four strokes of the cane. After his release, he went back to the United States and had trouble with the trauma.

Academics and lawyers The Independent Singapore spoke to said that this is because it has become fashionable to be anti-government, or oppositional.

Associate Professor Bilveer Singh of the Department of Political Science at the National University of Singapore (NUS) said: “There could be real grievances on the ground like poverty and getting short-changed because of foreign labour.

“At the same time, I think many of them believe they have a right to express themselves, and some of them might believe the government will accept it.”

Much of this notion could stem from sentiments from online media.

Peter Low, who leads his legal practice, said: “Of late, more people have been emancipated from political apathy; especially, the younger [Singaporeans] who have taken advantage of social media to express, in particular, their criticisms of, and dissatisfaction with, government.”

Singapore is transitioning from a more authoritarian model of governance to a democratic one, Bliveer said.

To the government’s credit, Bilveer said, it has been tolerant of most of the criticisms against the PAP, unless the criticism becomes libellous or when people break the law.

He said: “I believe the government is not perfect. The population is not perfect. I think we are still not familiar with how we can manage these expressions or criticisms.”Follow us on Social Media

Send in your scoops to news@theindependent.sg 

- Advertisement -

Unpopular opinion: Libel damages should be increased for those who crowdfund, says Calvin Cheng

Singapore -- Courts should take into consideration that libel damages can be crowdfunded and the amounts should be increased accordingly, says Mr Calvin Cheng. In a Facebook post on Saturday (Apr 17), the former Nominated Member of Parliament (NMP) contended that courts...

Migrant worker helps visually impaired senior cross the street at AMK

Singapore—In today’s jaded world, it’s easy to find news that angers or upsets us, and therefore good news of people’s kind acts never fails to bring joy. One such recent act of kindness was shown by a migrant worker who took the...

WP’s Raeesah Khan, Louis Chua distribute porridge in Sengkang for Ramadan 

Singapore—Workers’ Party (WP) Members of Parliament Louis Chua and Raeesah Khan distributed food among their constituents in Sengkang GRC at the weekend to mark Ramadan. They were at Block 182 Rivervale Crescent with grassroots workers at 5 pm on Saturday (Apr 17),...
Follow us on Social Media

Send in your scoops to news@theindependent.sg