‘Trade-offs are everything’: Retiree in Tokyo explains why moving back to Singapore isn’t a simple decision
A Singaporean living in Japan says moving home involves more than comparing the cost of living.
SINGAPORE: The question of how Singaporeans who have moved abroad view home has drawn another thoughtful response, this time from commentator Chris Kuan, who lives in Tokyo and shared a personal breakdown of what returning to Singapore would actually mean.
His Facebook post follows a recently published article in The Independent Singapore, covering a story in which Singaporeans living in New Zealand, the United States, South Korea, and Thailand reflected on the country they left.
Some described Singapore as overly urban and perfection-driven. Others praised its safety, efficiency, public housing, and transport, while saying that different countries offer different ways of living.
Kuan framed the debate around a simple idea: some who leave miss Singapore’s convenience and security, while others become more aware of the lifestyle trade-offs they would face if they returned. He stressed that his take was “personal,” acknowledging that others might see it differently.
“Trade-offs are everything,” he wrote in his post.
The case for coming home
On paper, Kuan said, moving back would leave him better off in several ways.
As a retiree living on capital income, he estimated that he would save the equivalent of a median Singaporean salary in capital income tax by returning. Someone still paying ordinary income tax would save even more, he noted.
He also expected to spend less on food, explaining that Japan is expensive relative to wages because agriculture and fishery subsidies distort consumer prices. Healthcare costs, in his experience, are about the same in both cities, and he would spend less on clothes in Singapore.
“That means I am better off in Singapore, right? But wait a second,” he wrote.
The case for staying
The story, however, changes once housing, cars and lifestyle come into the picture.
Kuan said the small detached house he lives in would easily cost two to three times as much in Singapore. He could afford one, he said, but it would leave less money for other things, such as weeks-long holidays in Europe.
His car would cost about eight times more in Singapore, and dining out, especially at the top end, is cheaper in Tokyo. A five- to six-course lunch at a one-Michelin-star French restaurant costs him about S$100 a person, excluding wine. In Singapore, he estimated, it would be two to three times that.
The real question
Kuan then asked himself whether he would actually need a detached house and a car in Singapore. His answer was probably not. He could live in a four- or five-room HDB flat and use ride-hailing, avoiding the steep premiums on landed property and car ownership.
However, that, he pointed out, is the catch. “Being financially ‘better off’ in Singapore requires a (downward?) adjustment in lifestyle. So how do you price that into the equation?”
That is before counting what he would give up: being able to drive out for a day or two to the mountains or the seaside, and access to a wider range of cultural events.
On safety, he said the two cities were about the same in his view, though some would argue Singapore is safer. “Leaving aside earthquakes and typhoons, how absolutely safe do you need to be, right?”
Newsletter
Get updates straight to your inbox
He was careful not to declare a winner, or to rule out moving back. “One never knows what curveball life throws you,” he wrote. “If I do return, it is gaining something, losing something and adjusting. There is no win-win unless all you care about is counting how much dollars and cents you get your hands on, and nothing else.”
Netizens react
Commenters largely agreed that the decision comes down to more than money.
“Quality of life. What will keep you happy?” one asked.
Several described Singapore as a place to build wealth, but not necessarily to enjoy it. “Singapore is great for wealth accumulation phase. Thereafter, [we] have to see,” one wrote. Another put it more bleakly: “Sad to say we’re forced to search for a better quality of living overseas. Singapore is for work and wealth accumulation if you are still able.”
One raised concerns about the next generation: “Singapore is getting too expensive to live and make a home for the latter generations with no generational wealth passed down. One needs to live a meaningful life without the stress of survival of the fittest.”