‘This incident was caused by chicken crossing the road’ — SG judge dismisses woman’s lawsuit against PHV driver who braked for the bird, orders her to pay S$15K instead

Nick Karean
|
3 m read
‘This incident was caused by chicken crossing the road’ — SG judge dismisses woman’s lawsuit against PHV driver who braked for the bird, orders her to pay S$15K instead
Photo: Nick Karean/AI illustration

Singapore court dismisses lawsuit against PHV driver who braked for chicken crossing the road

SINGAPORE: A chicken crossing the road has an unexpected ending in Singapore, with a woman losing her lawsuit against a private-hire vehicle (PHV) driver who braked to avoid hitting the bird.

The woman, Yvonne Chen Qianyun, sued the driver, Mr Tan Teng Kiat, for negligence, claiming his sudden braking caused her injuries. However, District Judge Jonathan Ng Pang Ern dismissed her claim and ordered her to pay S$15,000 in legal costs.

The incident happened on Feb 19, 2024, when Chen was travelling in Mr Tan’s vehicle along Holland Road, Channel NewsAsia (CNA) reported (Nov 19). The judgment was published on Nov 18.

Driver braked to avoid hitting the chicken

According to the court judgment, a bird crossed the path of another vehicle ahead, causing its driver to brake. Mr Tan then applied his brakes to avoid a collision with that vehicle.

Mr Tan said he was travelling at about 50 kmh and was roughly 10 metres behind the vehicle in front. The two passengers had different accounts of the bird’s movements. Mr Tan said the chicken flew across the road, while Chen said it was already on the road.

The judge said the difference didn't matter. What mattered was that the chicken crossing had caused the vehicle ahead to brake.

Chen argued that Mr Tan had failed to keep a safe following distance. She also claimed his braking was more forceful than necessary. Mr Tan maintained that he had enough distance and time to stop safely.

Judge finds driver acted reasonably in an emergency

After reviewing the case, Judge Ng found there was little Mr Tan could reasonably have done under the circumstances. His decision to brake was reasonable because he faced an emergency.

The judge acknowledged that Chen was an innocent passenger who suffered injuries in an incident beyond her control. However, he said the law doesn't automatically make someone responsible for every loss or injury suffered by another person.

The judge also noted that Chen had at least two other pending court claims involving separate road accidents. One concerned a September 2022 accident involving a PHV, while the other involved her husband's vehicle in October 2024.

Not every accident has someone to blame

The judge’s decision demonstrates the difference between suffering an injury and having someone legally responsible for it.

In this case, Mr Tan had to react to an unexpected hazard. The court found that his response was reasonable, even though his passenger suffered the consequences.

Newsletter

Get updates straight to your inbox

“The law does not seek out a tortfeasor for every loss that is suffered. In an imperfect world, some losses must lie where they fall,” the judge said.

The judge described the incident as one caused by a chicken crossing the road, calling it an unfortunate part of life’s uncertainties.

“This incident, caused as it was by a chicken crossing the road, was unfortunately, but also undoubtedly, part of the vicissitudes of life,” the judge added in his judgment.

It is an unusual case, but drivers must take reasonable care, yet they can't prevent every sudden hazard. Sometimes, an unfortunate accident is simply an accident.


Read more: 3 fatal traffic accidents in 3 days: Singaporean food delivery rider, 75, flung by car, dies after he coughs up blood