Home News Featured News Straight Talk: Singapore -- A democratic aristocracy?

Straight Talk: Singapore — A democratic aristocracy?




- Advertisement -

By Aretha Chinnaphongse, Jillian Colombo, Misaki Tan and AJ Jennevieve

Four interns ask two veteran journos a tricky or cheeky GE question.


Question: Are the leaders ‘natural aristocrats’?

- Advertisement -


PN Balji: The answer is a simple one. Yes, the 4G is becoming an aristocratic class. The moment LKY started paying the ministers unimaginable salaries, the roots were planted. Politics is a public service, not a money-making profession. The only thing we can hope for is that this group doesn’t become like the royal family in UK. 


Tan Bah Bah: Are they? Every society is supposed to have a natural aristocracy, otherwise, there would be chaos  – basically a headless group of people going nowhere in particular. The 4G leaders went to good schools and varsities. Usual scholar route, then top UK and US varsities. So very bright, no doubt. Majority from humble background, that is, not from “royal blue” families. Though Chan Chun Sing was once rumoured to be related to the Lee family which he denied. 

- Advertisement -

So how would they be “aristocrats” in the sense that they are natural leaders? That is the multi-million-dollar question. Good academic performance does not mean you will be a good leader. You either have it or you don’t. The first Prime Minister of Malaysia was a notoriously bad . Winston Churchill wasn’t top of his class. 

Many of the 4G leaders went through the PPS route – they showed their mettle as assistants ’s PMs. That’s how they became blue. Nothing natural. They still have to prove themselves to the reds – Singaporeans at large.


This is part of a GE series, Straight Talk, that will be published daily up till Cooling Off Day on Jul 9.Follow us on Social

- Advertisement -

Send in your scoops to news@theindependent.sg 

- Advertisement -

Sudden closure of Hong Lim Market leaves hawkers no choice but to throw away ingredients

Singapore — After the emergence of two new Covid-19 clusters on Friday (Jul 16), with Hong Lim Market & Food Centre being one of them, the sudden closure of the venue has left hawkers with no choice but to throw their...

Lim Tean: What economic benefits does Singapore derive from granting KTV operators a $50K grant to “Pivot” into an “F&B” outlet?

Singapore — Opposition People's Voice (PV) party leader Lim Tean took to social media to ask if there were economic benefits to extending a S$50,000 grant to KTV operators to pivot them into a food and beverage establishment. The questions, directed at...

Nurse harassed by Sengkang neighbours granted protection order

Singapore — After being harassed by their neighbours for over a year, a Singaporean nurse has been granted an expedited protection order (EPO), providing him and his family “an overwhelming sense of relief.” Muhammad Najib bin Ngasewan, who works at Sengkang General...
Follow us on Social Media

Send in your scoops to news@theindependent.sg