Netizens have mixed reactions to MPs’ proposals for restricting smoking at home

On Monday, September 10, Parliament passed amendments to the Smoking (Prohibition in Certain Places) Act, which gives officers of the National Environment Agency (NEA) more powers of enforcement as well as provides for more no-smoking zones.

However, certain MPs feel that this is not enough to protect people from the secondhand smoke of their neighbors, and are therefore proposing more restrictions.

Nee Soon GRC MP Louis Ng believes that more should be done to “protect people from secondhand smoke in their own homes.” Citing complaints from his constituents who say they are affected by neighbors who smoke in their balconies and windows, and who can only be relieved from this problem if neighbors who smoke move away.

Rahayu Mahzam, Jurong GRC MP, said that the only solution is to tell the neighbors to stop smoking at their windows and balconies, while Chia Shi-Lu, Tanjong Pagar GRC MP, a surgeon, voiced his apprehensions for the health of those who breathe in secondhand smoke.

Additionally, Lee Bee Wah, Nee Soon GRC MP, talked about the increase of conflicts between non-smokers and smokes who live in the same HDB flat. She disapproves that “residential homes remain out of the authorities’ regulation when it comes to smoking,” and suggests that the sale of tobacco can be restricted and that tases on cigarettes could be raised, for the purpose of helping smokers stop the habit of smoking.

Here are the other measures suggested by the MPs

• Prohibiting smoking in HDB flats and designating areas adjacent to HDB blocks specifically for smoking
• Banning smoking at home by a door or window 5 meters from a neighbor’s door or window
• Penalties for neighbors who have secondhand smoke coming from their homes

However, Amy Khor, the Senior Minister of State for the Environment and Water Resources said that “not everyone would support the view that the government should intrude into one’s private space on the issue of smoking.” Ms. Khor believes that overreach in regulating issues between neighbors could be detrimental to their relationships and harmony within the community.

Last February, Ms. Khor said in Parliament that to smoke within one’s own home is not within the government’s purview, and urged Parliament to have residents settle such issues amicably, urging smokers to exercise consideration about the negative effect of their smoking on their neighbors.

The MP’s suggested restrictions for smoking at home caused quite a heated discussion among netizens, many of whom agreed with them

Some vehemently disagreed, saying that the proposals were overly restrictive and curtailed people’s freedoms

Some suggested an outright ban on cigarettes altogether would be the smarter option if the concern is really people’s health

Yet others raised the issue of burning other things, which also affect people’s health