Home News "Women should not be penalised for being women" - WP questions whether...

“Women should not be penalised for being women” – WP questions whether Careshield Life is truly inclusive




- -

Workers’ parliamentarians were in tune with the pulse of the people as they challenged the Government’s justification of the requirements and premiums that will imposed on citizens when the compulsory Careshield Life goes into effect in 2030, during the parliamentary on Tuesday.

Echoing party chairman Sylvia Lim’s and secretary-general Pritam Singh’s questions, Non-constituency Member of Parliament (NCMP) Daniel Goh tackled three issues that he dubbed the “trilemma” of Careshield Life.

Goh first asked why women are being made to pay higher premiums than men and indicated that this makes it seem like women are penalised for something they cannot control – their gender. Next, Goh asked whether Eldershield will become unsustainable if the majority of policyholders switch to Careshield Life.

Finally, Goh expressed shock over the fact that the ElderShield Review Committee Report claims that 1 in 2 healthy people aged 65 and above today could become severely disabled in their lifetime and questioned whether this statistic is a case of extreme profiling:

- Advertisement -

CareShield Life Motion: Daniel Goh

Can CareShield Life truly be inclusive? Daniel Goh 吴佩松 argues that women should not be penalised for something that is not within their control – being born women – as they will be required to pay significantly higher premiums (about 25% higher) compared to men. Moreover, the division in auto-enrollment between those in their 40s, and those in their 50s and 60s would create a lost generation of retiring workers with less protection for long-term disability, when they are the ones who would need it most in the coming decade of the ageing society. Daniel also questions whether a much reduced ElderShield membership pool would become unsustainable for a competitive system of three private insurers, should most existing ElderShield members make the switch to CareShield Life. Would this end up penalising the remaining ElderShield members?Finally, Daniel expresses his shock at in the ElderShield Review Committee Report that 1 in 2 healthy people aged 65 and above today could become severely disabled in their lifetime. Given that the younger cohorts should lead healthier lives given better nutritional, lifestyle, environmental and healthcare conditions, he questions whether this statistic of a 50% chance is a case of extreme profiling of the population in terms of severe disability risk.Vid credit:

Posted by The Workers' Party on Wednesday, 11 July 2018

Meanwhile, the uproar over Careshield Life and Eldershield has been continuing unabated:


http://ww2.theindependent.sg/govt-still-claims-it-is-not-making-profits-after-collecting-3-3-billion-in-eldershield-premiums-and-only-paying-out-133-million/Follow us on Social Media

- Advertisement -

Send in your scoops to news@theindependent.sg 

- Advertisement -

81-year-old man unable to use MediSave for S$128 A&E bill, questions if it can be used to buy his coffin

Singapore — After being unable to use the S$46,000 in his MediSave account for a S$128 A&E bill, an 81-year-old man questioned if he would be able to even use the money to buy a coffin after he dies. In a Facebook...

Man says no need for mask after vaccination, spotted spitting near car

Singapore – A man was spotted spitting near a car and informing the owner that he did not need to wear a mask as he was vaccinated against Covid-19. An argument ensued between two members of the public at 205 Sims Avenue...

Confirmed Covid case of a woman from Jurong Fishery Port also reportedly worked part-time at KTV lounge

Singapore — A woman who allegedly works at Jurong Fishery Port also does part-time work in the evenings at a KTV lounge, according to a media report. Health Minister Ong Ye Kung said in a Facebook post on Monday (Jul 19) that...
Follow us on Social Media

Send in your scoops to news@theindependent.sg