Home News Featured News "What kind of historian are you?" - Thum Pingtjin draws flak for...

“What kind of historian are you?” – Thum Pingtjin draws flak for doubting whether LKY really received standing ovation in 1985 US Congress

- Advertisement -

Historian Dr Thum Pingtjin has drawn criticism online after he cast doubts over whether founding Prime Minister Lee Kuan Yew really received a standing ovation in the US Congress in 1985.

Sharing the photo above, Dr Thum – the co-ordinator of the University of Oxford’s Project Southeast Asia – wrote:

“Another from the archives:
“”At the end of (Lee’s speech to the joint session of the US Congress), there was a sustained standing ovation… Even before he started his speech, there was a standing ovation – such is the Prime Minister’s reputation.” – Straits Times, 10 October 1985.
“”(Lee) was addressing a sparsely attended joint session and drew polite applause.” – International Herald Tribune, 10 October 1985.
“Hmmm… now I’m wondering just how much of what Singaporeans believed to be LKY’s vaunted global reputation was actually manufactured by the government-controlled media, in the days when there were no alternative news sources?”

A netizen, however, helped prove that Lee Kuan Yew did indeed receive a standing ovation in the US Congress in 1985 by sharing a video that covered the event:

- Advertisement 1-

Dr Thum thanked the netizen for bringing the video to his attention as another netizen shared that the allegation that Lee Kuan Yew only received “sparse applause” originated from the Washington post.

Dr Thum then clarified in his original post: “EDIT: a comment below points to a youtube video of Lee’s speech, which does indeed draw a standing ovation at the close (but the video does not show the opening). I’ll see if I can dig up the IHT article to see if it reported the speech accurately. ”

Netizens writing in the comments section of Dr Thum’s post also felt that it could be the International Herald Tribune that reported inaccurately.

- Advertisement 2-

Several others, however, took the opportunity to slam Dr Thum for supposedly “being selective” in choosing his sources. These netizens questioned what kind of historian Dr Thum is and opined that his post “says a lot about (his) agenda”:

Meanwhile, some Facebook users came to Dr Thum’s defense and pointed out that some are so quick to accuse the historian of spreading lies. These netizens argued that the commenters who criticised Dr Thum may also suffer from confirmation bias since even if the International Herald Tribune is incorrect, it does not necessarily mean that The Straits Times is also completely accurate.

Follow us on Social Media

Send in your scoops to news@theindependent.sg 

- Advertisement -

Read More

Stories you might’ve missed, Jan 25

Leon Perera: We should never trust blindly in any government or institution FB screengrab: Leon Perera Singapore — Workers’ Party Member of Parliament Leon Perera (Aljunied GRC) pointed out that while Health Minister Ong Ye Kung recently echoed a phrase WP...

NFT earnings of S$7.5 million in 10 days for S’pore-based influencer Irene Zhao

Singapore — Singapore-based Chinese influencer and Instagram model Yuqing Irene Zhao listed her non-fungible token's (NFT), garnering purchases from prominent individuals like Galaxy Digital...

‘3 years and look how people still miss you’ — fans remember Aloysius Pang on his death anniversary

Singapore — It's been three years since actor Aloysius Pang died in an accident during a military training exercise, but he has been far...

Nagaenthran’s case: Appeal against death sentence adjourned, calls to spare his life continue

Singapore — An appeal from Nagaenthran K. Dharmalingam, a convicted Malaysian drug trafficker facing execution in Singapore, was adjourned on Monday (Jan 25). Ms Violet...

Shock & disappointment for loyal customer who finds cockroach in porridge, decides to support different outlet

Singapore — After finding a "fresh-looking" cockroach on his order of porridge from a Tampines outlet, a loyal customer decided to patronise a different...

Stories you might’ve missed, Jan 25

Leon Perera: We should never trust blindly in any government or institution FB screengrab: Leon Perera Singapore — Workers’ Party Member...

NFT earnings of S$7.5 million in 10 days for S’pore-based influencer Irene Zhao

Singapore — Singapore-based Chinese influencer and Instagram model Yuqing Irene Zhao listed her non-fungible token's (NFT), garnering purchases from...

‘3 years and look how people still miss you’ — fans remember Aloysius Pang on his death anniversary

Singapore — It's been three years since actor Aloysius Pang died in an accident during a military training exercise,...

Nagaenthran’s case: Appeal against death sentence adjourned, calls to spare his life continue

Singapore — An appeal from Nagaenthran K. Dharmalingam, a convicted Malaysian drug trafficker facing execution in Singapore, was adjourned...
Follow us on Social Media

Send in your scoops to news@theindependent.sg