Home News Featured News Singaporeans argue that it is the establishment that is complacent as British...

Singaporeans argue that it is the establishment that is complacent as British author says Singapore runs the risk of complacency

Several netizens said that while there is complacency in Singapore, the culture the ruling party created is to blame, not the people

Author

Date

Category

- Advertisement -

A British journalist’s book about Singapore and how it could suffer from complacency has drawn mixed views on social media, with many arguing that it is the establishment in Singapore that is complacent, not the people.

The writer, Nicholas Walton, had lived in Singapore for over three years as he worked for the Economist Intelligence Unit. During his time here, he walked across the entire country in one day and produced a book, entitled ‘Singapore, Singapura: From Miracle to Complacency,’ covering his thoughts about the country.

In his book, Mr Walton notes that modern Singapore is a “miracle” especially given its lack of natural resources and small size but wonders whether the nation’s achievements have “bred a dangerous sense of complacency among Singapore’s people?”

Pointing out that there is talk of a “Singapore model” in the globalised world today, Mr Walton said that there are “challenges ahead, from public complacency and the constraints of authoritarian democracy to changing geographic realities and the difficulties of balancing migration in such a tiny state.”

- Advertisement -

Highlighting Mr Walton’s book on his personal Facebook page, distinguished diplomat Tommy Koh wrote that he found the book interesting. Noting that Mr Walton’s previous book was on the Italian city of Genoa, Prof Koh felt that the author was wondering “whether Singapore’s success will endure or will it suffer the fate of Genoa.”

While some netizens appreciated Mr Walton’s views, others disagreed with his assessment. One netizen, Facebook user Stavros N. Yiannouka, said that he has “always found the framing of such historical analogies to be unhelpful.”

Noting that Genoa and its rival Venice were “remarkably successful city-state polities that endured for several centuries,” Mr Stavros pointed out that “rather than asking how can Singapore avoid the fate of Genoa or Venice, we should be asking what did those polities get right that allowed them to survive for so long in an environment that was hostile to city states.”

In a separate comment, Prof Koh said that he agreed with the netizen’s views. Others argued that while there is complacency in Singapore, the culture the ruling party created is to blame, not the people:

Meanwhile, Mr Walton commented on the thread and said that he was delighted Prof Koh had read the book. He added: “And even if you didn’t like it, I’d hope it made a visually arresting paperweight.”

Please follow and like us:
Tweet
Share
No tags for this post.
- Advertisement -

Biden will be nicer to China than Trump

Joseph Biden, the presumptive next US President, will be friendlier to China than US President Donald Trump, judging by Biden’s statements and cabinet selections. Biden’s more harmonious posture towards China will please leaders of various Asian countries including Singapore Prime Minister...

K Shanmugam: In Singapore, the right to speak freely goes with the duty to act responsibly

Singapore—Speaking at the 16th Religious Rehabilitation Group Seminar at Khadijah Mosque on Monday (Nov 24), K Shanmugam, the Minister for Law and Home Affairs, said that the threat of terrorism has not gone away though its “shape and nature” have changed. Citing...

Parliament receives 61 NMP proposal forms from the general public, groups

The Office of the Clerk of Parliament said yesterday (24 Nov) that Parliament has received 61 Nominated Member of Parliament (NMP) proposal forms. This is higher than the 48, 41 and 36 proposal forms that Parliament received in 2018, 2016 and...
Please follow and like us:
Tweet
Share
No tags for this post.
Follow Me
Tweet