Featured News Opinion How many has Singapore sent to the gallows?

How many has Singapore sent to the gallows?

The country is thought to have a high rate of execution relative to the size of its population

Author

Date

Category

- Advertisement -

By: Jeannette Chong-Aruldoss

The death penalty has been a part of crime and punishment in Singapore from day one.  Although there is a host of crimes under Singapore law which attract the death penalty, Singapore has by and large executed persons convicted of murder and, since the enactment of the Misuse of Drug Act in 1975, drug-trafficking.

Back in 2004, Singapore was put in the spotlight by a scathing paper, “Singapore – The death penalty: a hidden toll of executions”, published by Amnesty International criticising Singapore’s use of the death penalty.

In particular, the paper chastised Singapore for its high rate of execution relative to its population size. The paper said that more than 400 had been executed since 1991 up to the date of the paper, 15 January 2004.  How true is that?  Since Singapore became an independent nation in 1965, how many persons have Singapore executed?

- Advertisement -

I tried to find official judicial execution statistics, but it turned out to be a cat-and-mouse game.

On 12 October 2011, then newly elected Member of Parliament Pritam Singh from the Workers’ Party filed a written question for the Minister for Home Affairs (MHA), asking from 2004 to 2010, how many criminals had been hanged in Singapore and what was the breakdown in terms of foreigners, permanent residents and Singaporeans for each of those years.[1]  In reply, DPM Teo Chee Hean provided statistics indicating that from 2004 to 2010, a total of 38 people were executed, comprising 26 Singaporeans and 12 foreigners.

DPM Teo Chee Hean also stated that the Singapore Prison Service (SPS) publishes the number of judicial executions in its Prisons Annual Report and that those annual reports were publicly available on the SPS website.

DPM Teo Chee Hean’s statement gives the impression that the Singapore Government is transparent about execution statistics. It may seem to the casual observer that Pritam Singh’s question was unnecessary if execution statistics were publicly available on the SPS website.

In fact, Pritam Singh’s question was not redundant at all.  If you go to the SPS website[2], you will only find SPS annual reports from 2008 onwards.  SPS annual reports prior to 2008 are not obtainable from the SPS website (and I do not know where to find them).  Moreover, the 2008 annual report does not contain any statistics on judicial executions at all.  It is only starting with the 2009 Annual Report, that executions statistics are published in every Annual Report to date.  The 2009 Annual Report contains execution statistics for 2007, 2008 and 2009. So, it would be more accurate to say that execution statistics from 2007 onwards are publicly available on the SPS website.[3] Execution statistics prior to 2007 cannot be found on the SPS website.

Perhaps Pritam Singh was motivated to ask for the execution statistics from 2004 to 2010 because prior to filing his question, which DPM Teo Chee Hean answered on 12 October 2011, Pritam Singh could not find those figures anywhere.

Thanks to Pritam Singh’s question, official information on the number of persons executed in each year from 2004 to 2010 is on public record. Further, based on the SPS website, we also know the number of persons executed in each year from 2007 to 2019.

How about executions statistics prior to 2004?

Amnesty International’s paper published on 15 January 2004 prompted the Singapore Government to issue a rebuttal on 30 January 2004. Residing as footnote no. 4 at the end of the rebuttal was a set of statistics indicating that a total of 138 persons were executed “in the last 5 years”. Given the date of that rebuttal, “the last 5 years” would mean 1999 to 2003. Thanks to Amnesty International’s paper, another piece of official information was coughed up.

The Government’s rebuttal on 30 January 2004 indicated that a total of 138 persons were executed in the five years from 1999 to 2003, but did not provide the breakdown for each year between 1999 and 2003.  From the yearly statistics given in Parliament on 12 January 2001, we can see how many persons were hung in 1999 and 2000.  But how many persons were hung in each of the years 2001, 2002 and 2003?

Fortuitously, a set of official execution statistics that fell into the public domain inadvertently answered this question. On 24 September 2003, then Prime Minister Goh Chok Tong gave the BBC in an interview in which he glibly said that up to 80 people had been executed in the first nine months of 2003.

To correct the erroneous figure, the Singapore Government attached a note to the transcript of the BBC interview stating that 21 persons were executed in 2000, 27 in 2001 and 28 in 2002. [4] Thus, another set of official statistics fell out into the open. The number of persons executed in 2003 can be worked out by arithmetic.  Thus, the gap in the execution statistics was filled.

How about executions statistics prior to 1999?

Rolling up my sleeves, I went on my hands and knees to claw and trawl the graveyard of old Parliamentary reports.  My efforts were rewarded.  I found that on 12 January 2001, in reply to a question filed by then non-constituency member of parliament JB Jeyaretnam from the Workers’ Party, Wong Kan Seng provided the number of persons who have been hanged in Singapore for the years 1991-2000, giving the numbers year by year and splitting the number for each year into the various crimes for which they were hanged.[5]  Thanks to JBJ’s guts, another trove of official execution statistics was given out.

As for the number of persons hanged prior to 1991, my efforts to find those numbers have drawn a blank.  Hopefully, someone has or has found those numbers and if so, I would be keen to learn.

 In summary, the official sources which I managed to find are as follows:

  1. SPS website giving execution statistics from 2007 to 2019;
  2. Parliamentary report dated 12 October 2011 giving execution statistics from 2004 to 2010;
  3. Singapore Government’s rebuttal dated 30 January 2004 to Amnesty International’s paper giving execution statistics from 1999 to 2003;
  4. Note attached to the transcript of Goh Chok Tong’s interview with BBC released by the Singapore Government on 25 September 2003 giving number of persons executed in 2002, 2001 and 2000; and
  5. Parliamentary report dated 12 January 2001 giving execution statistics from 1991 to 2000.

Piecing them together, the total number of persons hanged in each year from 1991 to 2019 can be calculated. Below is a tabulation of the information provided by the official sources.  From the tabulation, the following conclusions can be quickly drawn:

  1. From 1991 to 2003 (13 years), 414 persons were executed, thus vindicating Amnesty International’s charge that more than 400 had been executed in Singapore since 1991 up to the date of their paper, 15 January 2004;
  2. From 2004 onwards, there has been a perceptible drop in the rate of executions for mysterious reasons; and
  3. From 1991 to 2019 (29 years), 491 persons were executed.

No doubt more observations or inferences will come to mind on further consideration of the statistics.

A set of information with gaps is incoherent. A complete set of figures is always useful. Which is why coherent factual information, especially information relating to state action carried out on behalf of the citizenry, should be made available for one to consider and ponder.

 Who knew that one has to be quite a sleuth to track down the number of persons hanged by the state.

I do feel I am like Sherlock Holmes solving a murder mystery, pardon the pun.

Photo: http://jeannettechongaruldoss.blogspot.com/2021/02/how-many-has-singapore-hung-from-gallows.html?m=1

Jeannette Chong-Aruldoss is a practising lawyer of more than 30 years’ standing who is interested in but does not specialise in the practice of criminal law. In uncovering the facts discussed in this article, her research tools were a good Wi-Fi connection to the internet and a bee in her bonnet.  Putting herself in the shoes of a layman, she did not avail of materials which are only accessible by subscription or otherwise unavailable to the general public.

This article was first published here.

 

[1] “Judicial Executions in Singapore” Parl. No. 12, Sess. 1, Vol. 88, Sitting No. 6 (21 October 2011)

[2] https://www.sps.gov.sg/news-about-us/publications

[3] Execution statistics from 2007 to 2019 are also available at https://data.gov.sg/dataset/judicial-executions

[4] “More people executed in Singapore”, AFP report published in The Age, 25 September 2003 https://www.theage.com.au/world/more-people-executed-in-singapore-20030925-gdwejk.html

[5] “Number of Persons Hanged” Parl. No. 9, Sess. 2, Vol. 72, Sitting No. 13 (12 January 2001)Follow us on Social Media

Send in your scoops to news@theindependent.sg 

- Advertisement -

K Shanmugam: If SG goes down racist route, eventually all Indians can be a target of hate

Singapore—In the wake of a hate crime last Friday (May 7) when a 55-year-old Singaporean-Indian woman was kicked in the chest and called racial slurs, racism and xenophobia were discussed in Parliament on Tuesday (May 11).  Minister for Law and Home Affairs...

Van beats traffic light and almost hits a woman pushing a baby in a stroller

Singapore - A Toyota Hiace van beat the traffic light and almost hit a woman who was crossing the road, pushing a baby in a stroller. Camera footage from another car showed that the Toyota Hiace driver picked up speed instead of...

Man stages Crazy Rich Asian-like mahjong scene to propose to girlfriend

Singapore—Proposal stories are always heartwarming if the other party responds with an ecstatic “yes!” But they’re pretty run-of-the-mill, as people have been coupling up since Adam and Eve. And there are proposals that are so OTT, we just have to write about them—and...
Follow us on Social Media

Send in your scoops to news@theindependent.sg 

Theindependent