“Why deprive the minority of Marsiling-Yew Tee of their rights?”: Ex-Association of Muslim Professionals director


Former Association of Malay Professionals (AMP) director Nizam Ismail has asserted that Halimah Yacob’s decision to contest the upcoming Presidential Election will dilute minority representation in Marsiling Yew-Tee GRC and in Parliament since she resigned as one of the Members of Parliament (MP) of the GRC and as Speaker of Parliament.

In a post published yesterday on Facebook page Suara Melayu Singapura, Mr Nizam opined that it wouldn’t be fair for other MPs to fill Halimah’s vacant position because they have their own full load of responsibilities.

Nizam seems to have foretold the future since it was announced today that Member of Parliament for Chua Chu Kang GRC, Zaqy Mohamad, will replace Halimah as adviser to Marsiling-Yew Tee GRC’s Grassroots Organisations, even though he is already an adviser to the Grassroots Organisations of the GRC he was elected in.

Zaqy Mohamad appointed as Halimah Yacob’s substitute in Marsiling-Yew Tee Grassroots Organisation

In his post, Nizam highlighted that Halimah’s resignation casts doubts on the basis of the GRC system which was instated to ensure minority representation in Parliament. Asserting that Halimah’s choice to give up her elected roles to contest the Presidential race may diminish the representation of minority aspirations and concerns, Nizam asked, “Why deprive the minority of Marsiling-Yew Tee of their rights?”

We republish his post in full:

“And so the non-newsy news gets announced, with Mdm Halimah Yacob announcing her candidacy for the reserved presidency.
“The reserved presidency was ostensibly done in a bit to protect multiculturalism, to give the Malay community a chance to have representation in the presidency, after a hiatus, post Yusof Ishak.
“Putting aside the skepticism and critique (and there are many) of the reserved presidency for the moment, is the Community better off in terms of representation, especially in light of the fact that there will be no by-election in Marsiling-Yew Tee GRC to find a replacement for Mdm Halimah?
“Well, the Community lost a Speaker of Parliament (the first woman Speaker too), and Malay MP in Parliament.
“And the Malay residents in Marsiling-Yew Tee GRC have lost their representative voice in Parliament.
“After all, the very purport of the GRC is to apparently ensure a certain level of minority representation in Parliament.
“And it is a considerable period of time till the next GE (which must be held by Jan 2021).
“The argument is that other MPs can stand in for Mdm Halimah.
“But (again putting aside critique of the GRC system for the moment) the raison d’être of the GRC system is precisely that the minority MP is there to represent minority aspirations and concerns.
“Why deprive the minority of Marsiling-Yew Tee of their rights?
“Also, the other MPs (whether of majority or minority ethnicity) would have had their full load of responsibilities too. It won’t be fair on them either.”

Ex-PAP MP, Inderjit Singh, also echoed Nizam’s sentiments in a Facebook post in late July. He opined that a sitting MP resigning from office to contest Presidential Election may go against spirit of Office as intended by Lee Kuan Yew.

Inderjit Singh: A sitting MP resigning from office to contest Presidential Election may go against spirit of Office as intended by Lee Kuan Yew


  1. You guys and gals still don’t get it. We’re living in a dictatorship disguised as a democracy. They’ll do whatever they want and no one can check them. Not the EP nor the judiciary.

  2. Zaqy is just like a man with two families. Can he give each of them his undivided attention? One side will sooner or later be “anak tiri”. Betul?

  3. If an Indian muslim can be declared as Malay, need more. Indian muslims donate to Sinda n not Mendaki. If they go to Mendaki seeking help as muslims, they are asked to seek help from SINDA. But they are compromise for the highest office. We Indians are happy to let Indian muslims go n get help from Mendaki. They have more choice now. They can cite Halimah n get help.

  4. There are lots of things really pissed me off in related to government own-self check own-self. PAP standard has dropped as compared when LKY was around. To those 69% who voted for the PAP….go n do some soul searching.

Comments are closed.